Digital Retailing
High-stakes purchases and complex multi-party buying decisions across consumer and commercial segments.
Inside this journey
-
Customer Discovery
Clarify dealer outcomes, pilot success signals (unique leads, digital-to-showroom conversion, time-in-store, F&I penetration), key stakeholders, and constraints like DMS/CRM integration and compensation impacts.
Discovery Questions
Start with the Big Picture — Tell Us About Your Store
- Briefly describe your rooftop or group — brands, size (units/year), and who ultimately signs deal rollouts.
- Who are the people we should expect to involve in this pilot from your side?
- What digital tools and systems are already in place at this rooftop (select all that apply)?
- Roughly how many retail opportunities (leads or walk-ins) does this rooftop generate per month?
- What are the top three internal priorities for your leadership team this year (e.g., margin, CSI, move-in time, growth)?
Are You Losing Customers Without Realizing It?
- How confident are you that your current online shopper experience creates incremental sales versus simply shifting showroom traffic?
- What percentage of closed deals in the last 12 months began their journey online (even if they finished in-store)?
- Tell us about a recent online lead that surprised you — either in quality or behavior. What stood out?
- How do you currently define and track a 'unique digital lead' versus a repeat/contact point?
- Which part of the online-to-showroom journey do you suspect causes the most drop-off (search, pricing, trade, credit, scheduling, salesperson handoff)?
What’s the Real Cost of 'Too Much Friction'?
- On average, how long does a digitally-started customer spend in the showroom compared with a typical walk-in?
- How does F&I penetration and per-deal F&I revenue for digitally-started deals compare to walk-ins today?
- Describe any compensation structures or commission rules that might be disrupted if deals are pre-structured online.
- Which operational steps add the biggest time-to-sale or create negotiation friction (select all that apply)?
- How does it feel to your sales team when an Internet start turns into a lengthy in-store process—frustrating, neutral, empowering?
If We Could Build Your Perfect Deal Flow, What Would Change?
- Imagine a digitally-started deal that arrives at your desk ready to close — what three things would make you call that a win?
- Which of these outcomes matter most to you for a pilot (pick up to three)?
- What are realistic numeric targets you’d accept for a 60–90 day rooftop pilot (e.g., X unique leads/month, Y% conversion uplift, Z minutes less time-in-store)?
- What parts of your current customer experience must remain unchanged for legal, brand, or compliance reasons?
- If we achieved those targets but a small group of salespeople resisted the change, how would you want to handle it?
Integration: The Make-or-Break Reality
- Which DMS and CRM power your rooftop and which of them have open APIs or partner integrations today?
- Do you have existing middleware or an integration partner (e.g., JENN/Apex, RouteOne, DealerBuilt) that we must work through?
- Are there any legal, security, or compliance constraints (credit consent, SSO, vendor firewalls) that would limit data access?
- How quickly could your IT team provide sandbox/API credentials, data mappings, and a test environment (typical lead time)?
- Who will be the owner for data mapping and go‑live sign-off on your side (title/role)?
People and Pay: Who Wins and Who Loses?
- If digitally-started deals shorten in-store time and shift pre-work to online, how do you expect that to affect salesperson compensation and morale?
- How are BDC/Internet leads currently credited and compensated (select all that apply)?
- Would you be open to a temporary incentive program for digitally-started deals during the pilot (e.g., bonus per closed digital start)?
- Which roles must receive formal training before go-live to avoid execution errors?
- Who has final approval authority for compensation changes or incentive trials?
Pilot Design — Let’s Make This Easy to Decide
- What are the non-negotiable commercial or data commitments you need from a vendor to run a pilot?
- Which pilot duration do you consider meaningful for decision-making?
- How many vehicles or customers would you like the pilot to include (select one)?
- What reporting cadence do you want during the pilot to feel informed but not overloaded?
- If the vendor suggests A/B tests (pricing display, trade messaging, F&I menu order), which areas are you most willing to experiment with?
Show Me the Proof — Monitoring, Acceptance, and Decision Points
- What is a single, clear acceptance criterion that would make you say ‘pilot succeeded’?
- Which KPIs must be tracked and reported for acceptance (select all that apply)?
- Who will review weekly pilot reports and who signs the final acceptance decision?
- How would you prefer issues to be raised and resolved during the pilot (channel and escalation path)?
- If the pilot misses targets but shows promise in one area (e.g., leads up but F&I down), what decision framework should we use?
Commitment & Next Steps — What's a Realistic Path Forward?
- Are you willing to commit to a controlled rooftop pilot that may require temporary workflow changes to prove measurable gains?
- What internal approvals are required (legal, owner, finance) and what is the expected timing for those approvals?
- Who will be the day-to-day point of contact for coordination, and who is the executive sponsor?
- What are realistic calendar windows for a 2–3 week integration period and a 60–90 day pilot start?
- What's the single biggest reason you might pause before launching a pilot, and what would remove that barrier?
-
Solution Experience
Translate the dealer’s current process into a shared future state by walking a realistic digitally-started deal end-to-end to confirm outcomes and workflow impact.
Experience Meetings
- Solution Experience — Prep: Data, Roles & One‑Sentence Current State
- Current State Mapping Workshop
- Future State Definition — Outcomes, KPIs & Acceptance
- Real Deal Walkthrough — Live End‑to‑End (Digitally‑Started Deal)
- Validation, Pilot Readiness & Pilot Parameters Decision
- CustomerNode to produce a gap list with owner and ETA for each integration/config issue found during the walkthrough.
- Present proposed one-sentence Future State
- Agree a concise Future State sentence that defines the operational improvement.
- Lock in measurable KPIs and numeric acceptance thresholds for the rooftop pilot.
- Assign owners for metric collection, reporting, and pilot signoff.
- Document the Future State sentence and distribute for stakeholder signoff.
- Finalize KPI definitions, targets, and the pilot acceptance checklist.
- Assign and confirm the metric owners and schedule the reporting cadence.
- Recap Current State, Consequence & Future State
- Demonstrate proof that the platform achieves the defined Future State for at least one live scenario.
- Obtain explicit validation from dealer SMEs for each step that it addresses the stated problem.
- Produce a prioritized list of integration/configuration gaps and workflow changes needed for pilot readiness.
- Introductions & Outcome of this meeting
- Dealer to confirm any required compensation or workflow policy changes to handle digitally‑started deals.
- Agree on final platform configuration changes and schedule for implementation before pilot.
- Review Key Findings & Proof Points
- Achieve explicit go/no‑go signoff for pilot readiness or a clear remediation plan with dates.
- Lock the pilot scope, rooftop config, KPI targets, and reporting cadence.
- Confirm training and change management plan owners and timeline.
- Finalize and sign the pilot acceptance checklist with named signatories.
- Schedule the technical integration window (2–3 weeks) and assign technical leads.
- Set training dates and owner for BDC/sales workflows prior to pilot go‑live.
- Establish the first pilot performance report date and designated recipients.
- Produce a clear one-sentence Current State statement signed by dealer SMEs.
- Document quantified consequence metrics needed for the experience.
- Obtain commitments for data, test access, and named stakeholders.
- Agree on 1–3 live deal scenarios to be used in the walkthrough.
- Dealer to deliver sample DMS/CRM/inventory extracts and historical metrics (conversion, time-in-store, F&I rates).
- CustomerNode to provide test API access instructions and data format requirements.
- Named decision owner to confirm acceptance criteria owners and signoff process.
- Confirm scheduled date/time for the live walkthrough and attendees.
- Read-back the one-sentence Current State
- Create a validated, step-by-step current process map with named owners for each step.
- List top failure modes and attach numeric consequences to each (e.g., X lost deals/month).
- Identify integration and comp-model constraints that must be respected in the future state.
- Produce a documented process map and circulate to participants for signoff.
- Prepare a short list of the top 5 failure modes with supporting metrics.
- IT to confirm technical constraints (DMS fields, CRM API limits, lender interfaces) in writing.
- Review Open Gaps, Risks & Mitigations
- Live Scenario Setup
- Create the one-sentence Current State
- Map Future Flow to Eliminate Specific Breakpoints
- Stepwise Process Walkthrough (Lead → Deal)
- End‑to‑End Execution — Customer Journey
- Confirm Pilot Parameters and Acceptance Checklist
- Identify Breakpoints & Failure Modes
- Define Pilot KPIs and Numeric Targets
- Surface the Consequence
- Acceptance Criteria & Decision Rules
- Data & Access Checklist
- Tieback & Validation Pauses
- Training & Workflow Enablement Plan
- Quantify Consequences
- Go/No‑Go Signoff & Next Steps
- Stakeholder RACI and Decision Criteria
- Identify Measurement Owners & Reporting Cadence
- Exercise Exception Paths
- Integration & Compensation Constraints
- Capture Configuration Gaps & Workflow Changes
- Select Live Deal Scenarios & Personas
-
Solution Scope
Define modules (search, payment calc, trade, credit app, F&I, desking), integrations, pilot rooftop configuration, roles, and measurable acceptance criteria.
Scope Configuration
- DMS Inventory Feed Integration
- CRM Lead Sync and Field Mapping
- Lender Rate and Real‑Time Decision Integration
- Real‑Time Payment Calculator Deployment
- Trade‑in Valuation Engine Activation
- Credit Application Soft‑Pull Enablement
- F&I Menu Mapping and Digital Presentation
- Online Deal Structuring and Desking Engine
- Checkout and Reservation (Deposit) Processing
- Digital Deal Summary and Contract PDF Generation
- Sales Team Enablement Training for Digital Deals
- BDC Response Template Deployment
- Performance Analytics Dashboard Activation
- A/B Test Variant Deployment for Pricing and UI
Scope Questions
DMS Inventory Feed Integration
- Which DMS vendor(s) do you use on the pilot rooftop?
- Do you currently expose an inventory feed for third-party integrations?
- Which inventory fields must be included in the feed (VIN, stock#, price, mileage, photos, options)? List any mandatory fields.
- What is your required update cadence for inventory (real-time, hourly, daily)?
- Are photos, option packages, and condition notes available at VIN level in the feed?
- Who is the technical owner for DMS access and approvals (name/role/contact)?
CRM Lead Sync and Field Mapping
- Which CRM(s) will receive leads from the platform on the pilot rooftop?
- Do you require real-time lead push (webhook/API) or scheduled batch sync?
- Which lead fields must be mapped to your CRM (name, phone, email, VIN, offer, payment, lead source)? Specify any required custom fields.
- What deduplication or lead matching rules should apply (match on phone, email, VIN)?
- Do you need lead status/workflow automation created in the CRM (e.g., Digitally Started → Appointment Set)?
- Who will own CRM mapping approvals and testing on the dealer side (name/role)?
Lender Rate and Real‑Time Decision Integration
- Which lender types do you want integrated for real-time rates/decisions on pilot (captive, bank, credit union, finance companies)?
- Do you require real-time credit decisioning (instant soft pre-qual) or rate lookup only?
- How are lender integrations currently handled (SFTP, API, portal access, aggregator)?
- What customer data fields will be provided to lenders for decisions (SSN last4, DOB, income, address)?
- Are there state-specific lender restrictions or compliance requirements we should know about?
- Who signs off on lender integrations and will coordinate test credentials?
Real‑Time Payment Calculator Deployment
- Which inputs should the calculator expose to customers (price, tax, fees, trade, down payment, term, APR)?
- Should the calculator display multiple payment scenarios (term and down payment variants) or a single recommended payment?
- Are there pricing guardrails or minimum margins required to protect profitability?
- Do payments need to match the DMS/desking output exactly for acceptance (tolerance threshold $/%)?
- Do you require taxes and registration to be estimated by ZIP code or calculated from DMS?
- Who will approve payment rule logic and test cases on the dealer side?
Trade‑in Valuation Engine Activation
- Do you have a preferred trade valuation provider to activate (KBB, NADA, Black Book, proprietary)?
- Should trade valuation be shown as an instant online estimate, or a conditional offer requiring appraisal?
- Do you want trade adjustments based on condition or reconditioning costs to be visible to customers?
- Do trade values need to sync to the DMS as pending trades with VIN reference?
- Are photos and vehicle history reports required as part of the trade flow?
- What acceptance criteria define a successful trade integration (e.g., VIN match rate, valuation variance)?
Credit Application Soft‑Pull Enablement
- Will you enable soft-pull prequalification (no hard inquiry) on the pilot?
- Which data fields are required to complete the soft-pull application (SSN last4, full SSN, DOB, income)?
- Which soft-pull provider or aggregator will be used (RouteOne, Dealertrack, other)?
- What consent and disclosure wording must appear prior to the soft-pull in your state(s)?
- What SLA do you require for prequalification responses (seconds, minutes)?
- Who will handle privacy/compliance sign-off (legal/GM/IT)?
F&I Menu Mapping and Digital Presentation
- Do you have a digital F&I menu file to import (CSV, XML, DMS export)?
- Which F&I products must be available by lender or by vehicle (GAP, service contract, appearance, prepaid maintenance)?
- Should product pricing be static, percentage-based, or based on lender rules?
- Do you require product descriptions, images, and disclosures visible to consumers?
- Do F&I selections need to map back to the DMS for contract printing and revenue posting?
- Who will review and approve the F&I menu mapping and legal disclosures?
Online Deal Structuring and Desking Engine
- Which deal types must be supported in desking (cash, finance, lease)?
- What desking rules need to be enforced (reserve, reserve splits, front/back gross, doc fees, incentives)?
- Does the dealer require overrides, manager approval steps, or audit trails for edits?
- Should the desk push finalized deals to the DMS with a specific transaction format or fields?
- Are incentives and manufacturer programs to be applied automatically or manually?
- What are the acceptance criteria for a successful deal export (field completeness, error rate threshold)?
Checkout and Reservation (Deposit) Processing
- Which payment methods should be accepted for deposits (card, ACH, third-party wallets)?
- Do you have a preferred payment gateway or merchant account?
- What deposit/refund policy should be enforced (amount, refundable/non-refundable, timeout)?
- Is PCI compliance handled by the dealer or should the platform manage tokenization?
- Do you require invoice/receipt generation tied to deposit transactions and stored in DMS/CRM?
- Who will provide merchant account credentials and sign documentation for payment processing?
Digital Deal Summary and Contract PDF Generation
- Do you require templated deal summaries and fully populated contract PDFs per state?
- Which e-signature provider do you prefer (DocuSign, AdobeSign, other) or will you use DMS signing?
- Should generated PDFs be stored back into the DMS, CRM, and platform records?
- Are there specific disclosures or state-required language that must be included in the PDF?
- What acceptance criteria define a correct contract PDF (field completeness, legal sign-off)?
- Who will approve contract templates and coordinate e-signature testing?
-
Mutual Commit
Agree pilot length, commercial terms, data/access commitments, success metrics, and decision criteria for broader rollout.
Agreement Modules
- Non-Disclosure Agreement (NDA)
- Statement of Work (SOW)
- Pilot Agreement / Addendum
- Commercial Terms & Pricing Schedule
- Data Processing & Access Agreement (DPA)
- Integration & Technical Access Authorization
- Success Metrics & Acceptance Criteria Annex
- Pilot Governance & Escalation Plan
- Sales Compensation & Workflow Impact Agreement
- Change Order & Scope Modification
- Termination & Exit Plan
- Billing Authorization & Payment Method
- Publicity & Reference Consent
-
Deployment
Operationalize rollout with readiness checks, enablement, and outcome validation.
-
Pre-Deployment Readiness
Confirm technical access, data mappings (DMS, inventory, lenders, F&I menu), owners, and risk controls required for integration and pilot execution.
Readiness Questions
What’s Driving This Change?
- What’s the main reason you’re exploring an online retailing platform right now?
- How long have you been considering a digital retailing solution for this rooftop or group?
- Which digital capabilities do you already have in place today?
- Tell us the most recent example where a digital change at your store clearly helped or hurt sales—what happened?
- If this pilot delivered no new customers but made in-store interactions shorter and smoother, how would you feel about that outcome?
Are We Just Moving Leads, Not Sales?
- What if this platform simply reroutes existing showroom shoppers into a different queue—would that be a win or a problem for you?
- What evidence have you seen that digital channels are bringing truly incremental customers versus shifting existing traffic?
- Which of these metrics do you currently track to assess channel incrementality?
- What minimum uplift in incremental sales would make a pilot successful for you (even if profitability per deal changes)?
- Can you share an example where a new customer channel looked promising initially but didn’t deliver—what did you learn?
Who’s Steering This Ship — Who’s Actually Accountable?
- If the GM says 'go' but IT says 'no', who ultimately makes the call for this rooftop?
- Which roles must be actively involved in the pilot (pick all that apply)?
- Who will be the day-to-day owner for pilot operations at the rooftop (title/name)?
- How do you prefer decisions to be made during the pilot—consensus, GM sign-off, or pre-assigned owner?
- Have you run a 60–90 day pilot like this before? If yes, what was the cadence and who signed off at the end?
Integration Nightmares or Smooth Sailing?
- If your DMS or CRM can’t share clean, mapped data, is a 2–3 week integration realistic or fantasy?
- Which DMS and CRM systems are in use at this rooftop (select all that apply)?
- How is your inventory currently delivered to external tools?
- What lender integrations do you already have or plan to require (name lenders or networks)?
- How is your F&I product menu currently managed and where is it stored?
- Do you have a sandbox/test environment and credentials available for the DMS, inventory feed, and lender APIs?
- Are there firewall, VPN, or vendor approval steps that typically delay integrations at this rooftop? If so, describe.
Money, Compensation, and Team Feelings
- Would your sales or BDC teams feel threatened if more of the deal was structured before showroom interaction?
- How are your sales and internet teams currently compensated (select all that apply)?
- Would you consider adjusted compensation for digitally-started deals (e.g., fixed fee for BDC, different GPU)?
- What are your expectations for F&I penetration on digitally-started deals versus walk-ins?
- What internal training bandwidth exists to onboard sales and BDC for the pilot (hours per week or resources)?
- How would you communicate and manage team sentiment about this change—formal meeting, town hall, 1:1s, or another approach?
Pilot Success — What Would Make This Worthwhile?
- If after 90 days you could only show one metric to greenlight rollout, which single figure would convince you?
- What target number of unique incremental leads over 60–90 days would you consider a success?
- What is the minimum acceptable digital-to-showroom conversion percentage for the pilot to be considered promising?
- How much reduction in average customer time-in-store would be meaningful to you?
- Beyond raw metrics, what qualitative signals would make you feel confident about rolling out (examples: staff adoption, customer NPS, reduced paperwork)?
- What is your acceptable ROI timeline after rollout (months to break-even)?
What Could Go Wrong — And Who’s Responsible?
- What’s the single failure scenario that would make you pull the plug during or immediately after the pilot?
- Who will own technical incidents during the pilot (internal role and backup)?
- What escalation path and SLA expectations do you require for critical issues during the pilot?
- Which risk controls are mandatory before we can go live (select all that apply)?
- Are there contractual or compliance approvals needed from your side (legal, finance, insurance) before a pilot can start?
- What level of outage or data error tolerance can you accept during the pilot?
Can We Move Fast Without Tripping? — Planning the First 30 Days
- Could your team commit to a contiguous 2–3 week technical integration window followed by a monitored pilot period?
- Which internal resources will be available during the integration (list titles or names)?
- What is your preferred target start window for the pilot?
- What reporting cadence would you like during the pilot to feel informed but not overwhelmed?
- Who should be added to the shared pilot communication channel (names/titles) and what is your preferred channel (Slack, Teams, email)?
- Are there any outstanding budget, contract, or approval items we should resolve before scheduling work (please describe)?
-
Deployment Enablement
Execute integrations, configure pricing/desking rules, train BDC and sales workflows, and schedule the 2–3 week technical work followed by pilot go‑live.
-
Pilot Validation Checklist
Verify data flows, tracking of target metrics, reporting cadence, and acceptance criteria during the 60–90 day rooftop pilot to inform roll/no-roll decisions.
Validation Questions
Start Here — A Quick Snapshot of Your Role
- Which of the following best describes your role today?
- How many rooftops and total rooftops does your group operate (or is this a single rooftop)?
- Roughly what share of your retail vehicle inquiries today begin online (lead form, Chat, digital app, etc.)?
- When a deal is started online today, whose workflow owns it once the customer arrives at the dealership?
- Tell us one recent win or moment that makes you optimistic about your current online-to-in-store process.
Are You Moving Market Share—or Just Moving Customers Around?
- What evidence makes you believe digital retailing will create net-new sales instead of just shifting your existing showroom traffic?
- Compared to walk-ins, how do you expect leads started digitally to perform on these metrics?
- Have you ever run an experiment or pilot aimed specifically at proving incremental sales from online tools? If yes, what did you learn?
- What would feel like convincing proof that the platform is generating net-new business for your rooftop?
- Who internally will push back most if the platform appears to cannibalize floor traffic, and why?
Where the Customer Journey Breaks — What Actually Frustrates You?
- What is the single biggest pain point when customers start a deal online and then show up in person?
- At which stage do you see the highest drop-off: initial search, trade valuation, payment calc, credit app, or desking/F&I?
- How long does a typical digitally-started customer spend in the showroom today (estimate in minutes)?
- Where do your teams most commonly lose momentum—BDC handoff, sales follow-up, F&I alignment, lender response time, or something else?
- Share an example of a recent digitally-started deal that went sideways—what happened and how did it feel for the customer and your team?
Who’s In The Room — Champions, Skeptics, and Quiet Blockers
- If we brought this pilot to your rooftop for 60–90 days, whose explicit approval would we need to start (select all that apply)?
- Who will be the final decision-maker on whether to expand beyond the pilot?
- Who on your team is most likely to push back on rollout because of compensation structure or perceived threat to commissions?
- How would you describe the general attitude of your salesfloor toward digital tools that change in-store workflow?
- What internal change management resources can we rely on (training time, coaching, role champions)?
The Tech Reality Check — Integrations, Data, and Access
- Which DMS(s) and CRM(s) does this rooftop use?
- Do you have API access or a middleware partner for DMS/CRM connections today?
- What lender connectivity exists today for real-time rate/decisioning—single lenders, dealer networks, or manual submissions?
- What are the non-negotiable data fields or feeds we must map for you to accept a pilot (select all that apply)?
- How do you currently verify data integrity between systems—manual checks, nightly syncs, or automated reconciliation?
- Are there legal/privacy or lender-specific approvals required before we can send customer data during a pilot?
What Would Success Actually Look Like — Beyond Vanity Metrics
- If the pilot is wildly successful, what three measurable outcomes would you point to when reporting to the owner/board?
- Which of these metrics matter most to your leadership when evaluating a pilot?
- What is your current baseline for unique digital leads per month (estimate)?
- What percentage uplift in those key metrics would make you comfortable recommending a roll?
- How will you determine whether gains are causally tied to the platform versus market or OEM promotions?
Designing a Pilot That Actually Answers the Question
- Would you be willing to run a 60–90 day rooftop pilot with agreed tracking, or do you prefer a shorter/longer test?
- Which rooftop configuration would give you the cleanest signal: single-store pilot, matched-pair stores, or phased multi-store?
- What minimum sample size (unique digital leads or completed digital deals) would make the pilot results statistically credible to you?
- Who will own daily operations and troubleshooting during the pilot (names/titles)?
- What cadence and format do you want for pilot reporting (weekly dashboard, bi-weekly review, live access to analytics)?
Money, Margins, and Motivations — The Financial Conversation
- How are you most concerned the platform could affect per-deal economics (check all that apply)?
- What is an acceptable monthly or per-deal cost structure for a pilot to make the economics palatable?
- Would you accept temporary adjustments to compensation plans for digitally-started deals during the pilot (e.g., guaranteed split, bonus for digital closes)?
- How sensitive would leadership be to an initial dip in F&I penetration if total closed deals and gross dollars rose?
- What financial reports or P&L views do you need to evaluate pilot profitability?
Risks, Compliance, and Customer Experience Concerns
- What are your top three compliance, legal, or privacy concerns about moving more of the deal online?
- Have lenders or compliance teams ever rejected digital signatures/data transfer methods in your experience?
- How important is maintaining a consistent CX between digital and showroom (e.g., same F&I offers, same price transparency)?
- What customer segments do you worry might be alienated by a more digital-first experience?
- If a negative customer experience happened during the pilot, what escalation path should we use?
What Would Make You Confident to Move Fast?
- If we could guarantee one thing at pilot start, what guarantee would change your openness the most (data security, no-cost pilot, guaranteed uplift, training support)?
- What minimum documentation or artifacts do you need before signing a pilot (SOW, data flow diagrams, security assessment, commercial terms)?
- What timeline would you be comfortable with from agreement to go‑live, assuming integrations are straightforward?
- What would you want to see in week 1, week 3, and week 8 of the pilot to feel it’s on track?
Commitments and Next Steps — Who Does What, When
- Who will be our primary point(s) of contact and their preferred communication method (email, Slack, phone)?
- What internal approvals or signatures are needed before we can begin technical access?
- Are there blackout dates or peak sales periods when we should not run a pilot?
- What would a ‘go/no-go’ decision look like at pilot end—who signs it off and what docs are required?
- Is there anything else we haven’t asked that you think will make or break a successful pilot?
-
-
Success
Review pilot performance against agreed metrics, capture learnings, and maintain a shared channel for issues and enhancement requests to drive broader rollout.
Success Reviews
- Pilot Performance Review — Executive
- Operational Validation — Sales & BDC
- Technical & Data Review — IT & Integrations
- Learnings & Enhancements Workshop — Product, Ops & Customer
- Rollout Planning & Commercial Agreement
Issues & Enhancements
- Create the prioritized enhancement backlog in the agreed tracking channel and assign owners and target dates.
- Confirm that the digitally‑started deal workflow delivers the intended future state in practice, not just in theory.
- Surface and document operational gaps and immediate process changes required before rollout.
- Assign owners and schedule training to address identified skill or script gaps.
- Update BDC and sales scripts and handoff checklist to reflect validated process changes.
- Schedule and run a role‑play training session for BDC and sales within two weeks.
- Document 3 representative pilot deals as case studies for onboarding/training materials.
- Current Integration Health Snapshot
- Confirm technical readiness and data integrity for scaling beyond the pilot or define required fixes before rollout.
- Agree on prioritized defect list, owners, and SLAs for remediation with clear timelines.
- Validate tracking and attribution so leadership can trust the reported pilot metrics.
- Create a prioritized technical defect list with owners, target fix dates, and verification steps.
- Implement analytics event fixes and run an integrity check on historical pilot data.
- Schedule a technical re‑signoff meeting after fixes are completed (target within 2 weeks).
- Synthesis of Top Pilot Learnings
- Capture a complete, prioritized enhancement backlog with acceptance criteria and owners.
- Agree on a shared channel and governance for issues and enhancement requests to enable transparent tracking.
- Define validation plans so each change has measurable success criteria post‑release.
- Opening & Objectives
- Set up the shared communication channel and the triage cadence (weekly or biweekly).
- Draft A/B test plans or pilot extension scopes for the top 2 enhancements and schedule execution.
- Confirm Decision Rationale
- Secure agreement on commercial terms and the phased rollout plan aligned to pilot learnings.
- Confirm resource commitments, training plan, and support model for the rollout.
- Document risk mitigations and assign owners for each identified risk area.
- Execute contract amendment or PO reflecting agreed commercial terms and pilot credits, if any.
- Publish a detailed rollout schedule with wave owners, technical windows, and training dates.
- Create a launch playbook that includes rollback criteria, escalation paths, and a 30/60/90 day post‑roll metrics review cadence.
- Ensure executive alignment on whether pilot results meet the agreed success criteria and business expectations.
- Secure a clear decision (rollout, extend, or iterate) with named owners and timeline.
- Surface any commercial or compensation issues that must be resolved before rollout.
- Produce a one‑page executive summary with KPIs, financial impact, and recommended decision for distribution to stakeholders.
- If approved to roll, issue a target rollout timeline and assign a rollout lead and executive sponsor.
- If conditional or pause decision, list gating requirements and deadlines for follow-up decision.
- Pre‑work & Expectations
- Data Flow Verification (DMS, Inventory, CRM, Lenders, F&I Menu)
- One‑Sentence Current Operational State
- Commercial Terms & Pricing Adjustments
- Capture & Clarify Enhancement Requests
- One‑Sentence Current State (Pilot Summary)
- Prioritization Exercise (Impact / Cost / Urgency)
- Rollout Phasing & Timeline
- Metrics Dashboard Walkthrough
- Live Walkthrough: Representative Digitally‑Started Deal(s)
- Error Log & Incident Triage
- Consequence & ROI Analysis
- Analytics, Attribution & Event Tracking
- Define Success Criteria & Validation Plan for Top Items
- Metrics by Workflow & Handoff Quality
- Resource, Training & Support Plan
- Security, Access, & Risk Controls
- Frontline Feedback & Customer Sentiment
- Risk Mitigation & Change Management
- Shared Channel & Governance Setup
- Future State Recommendation
- Decision & Criteria Confirmation
- Fix Plan, Ownership & SLA
- Release & Testing Schedule
- Issues, Workarounds, and Quick Wins
- Sign‑offs, Contracting & Next Milestones