Industrial & Manufacturing Automotive Dealership Technology & Operations

Digital Retailing

High-stakes purchases and complex multi-party buying decisions across consumer and commercial segments.

Roadster CarNow AutoFi Tekion
Inside this journey
  1. Customer Discovery

    Clarify dealer outcomes, pilot success signals (unique leads, digital-to-showroom conversion, time-in-store, F&I penetration), key stakeholders, and constraints like DMS/CRM integration and compensation impacts.

    Discovery Questions

    Start with the Big Picture — Tell Us About Your Store

    • Briefly describe your rooftop or group — brands, size (units/year), and who ultimately signs deal rollouts.
    • Who are the people we should expect to involve in this pilot from your side? Options: Dealer Principal / Owner, General Manager, Internet Sales Manager (ISM), BDC Manager, IT/Systems Admin, Finance Manager / F&I Director, Fixed Ops / Service Manager, Other
    • What digital tools and systems are already in place at this rooftop (select all that apply)? Options: CDK, Dealertrack, Reynolds & Reynolds, DealerSocket, Vinsolutions, Salesforce, Dealer.com / Dealer Inspire, Current digital retailing vendor, None, Other
    • Roughly how many retail opportunities (leads or walk-ins) does this rooftop generate per month? Options: Under 100, 100–300, 301–600, 601–1,200, 1,200+
    • What are the top three internal priorities for your leadership team this year (e.g., margin, CSI, move-in time, growth)?

    Are You Losing Customers Without Realizing It?

    • How confident are you that your current online shopper experience creates incremental sales versus simply shifting showroom traffic? Options: Very confident, Somewhat confident, Unsure, Not confident
    • What percentage of closed deals in the last 12 months began their journey online (even if they finished in-store)? Options: Unknown, 0–10%, 11–25%, 26–50%, 51%+
    • Tell us about a recent online lead that surprised you — either in quality or behavior. What stood out?
    • How do you currently define and track a 'unique digital lead' versus a repeat/contact point? Options: CRM lead record, Analytics session ID, Phone call attribution, Third-party attribution, We don't have a clear definition, Other
    • Which part of the online-to-showroom journey do you suspect causes the most drop-off (search, pricing, trade, credit, scheduling, salesperson handoff)? Options: Vehicle search/UX, Payment/price clarity, Trade valuation, Credit application, Appointment scheduling, BDC/hand-off process, Other

    What’s the Real Cost of 'Too Much Friction'?

    • On average, how long does a digitally-started customer spend in the showroom compared with a typical walk-in? Options: Less than half the time, About half the time, About the same, Longer than walk-ins, We don't track this
    • How does F&I penetration and per-deal F&I revenue for digitally-started deals compare to walk-ins today? Options: Higher, About the same, Lower, We haven't measured
    • Describe any compensation structures or commission rules that might be disrupted if deals are pre-structured online.
    • Which operational steps add the biggest time-to-sale or create negotiation friction (select all that apply)? Options: Manual DMS desking, Manual trade appraisal process, Offline lender submissions, Paper credit applications, F&I menu not mapped, BDC handoffs, Other
    • How does it feel to your sales team when an Internet start turns into a lengthy in-store process—frustrating, neutral, empowering? Options: Frustrating, Neutral, Empowering, Depends on the deal

    If We Could Build Your Perfect Deal Flow, What Would Change?

    • Imagine a digitally-started deal that arrives at your desk ready to close — what three things would make you call that a win?
    • Which of these outcomes matter most to you for a pilot (pick up to three)? Options: Unique leads generated, Digital → showroom conversion rate, Reduction in time-in-store, F&I penetration on digital deals, Per-deal gross/profit, Customer satisfaction/CSI, BDC efficiency
    • What are realistic numeric targets you’d accept for a 60–90 day rooftop pilot (e.g., X unique leads/month, Y% conversion uplift, Z minutes less time-in-store)?
    • What parts of your current customer experience must remain unchanged for legal, brand, or compliance reasons?
    • If we achieved those targets but a small group of salespeople resisted the change, how would you want to handle it?

    Integration: The Make-or-Break Reality

    • Which DMS and CRM power your rooftop and which of them have open APIs or partner integrations today? Options: CDK Global, Reynolds & Reynolds, Dealertrack, DealerSocket, VinSolutions, Salesforce, Other, Unsure / need IT input
    • Do you have existing middleware or an integration partner (e.g., JENN/Apex, RouteOne, DealerBuilt) that we must work through? Options: Yes - middleware in place, Yes - integration partner, No, Unsure
    • Are there any legal, security, or compliance constraints (credit consent, SSO, vendor firewalls) that would limit data access? Options: Credit consent restrictions, Firewall/VPN restrictions, Contractual vendor clauses, No constraints, Unsure / need IT
    • How quickly could your IT team provide sandbox/API credentials, data mappings, and a test environment (typical lead time)? Options: Within 1 week, 1–2 weeks, 3–4 weeks, More than 4 weeks, Unknown
    • Who will be the owner for data mapping and go‑live sign-off on your side (title/role)? Options: IT/Systems Admin, BDC Manager, General Manager, Third-party integrator, Other

    People and Pay: Who Wins and Who Loses?

    • If digitally-started deals shorten in-store time and shift pre-work to online, how do you expect that to affect salesperson compensation and morale?
    • How are BDC/Internet leads currently credited and compensated (select all that apply)? Options: BDC owns lead until sale, Salesperson credited on delivery, Split credit model, No formal rule, Other
    • Would you be open to a temporary incentive program for digitally-started deals during the pilot (e.g., bonus per closed digital start)? Options: Yes, Maybe — depending on terms, No
    • Which roles must receive formal training before go-live to avoid execution errors? Options: BDC agents, Internet Sales Managers, Sales consultants, F&I managers, Finance/Accounting, Service advisors, Other
    • Who has final approval authority for compensation changes or incentive trials? Options: Dealer Principal, General Manager, HR / Payroll, Group Compensation Committee, Other

    Pilot Design — Let’s Make This Easy to Decide

    • What are the non-negotiable commercial or data commitments you need from a vendor to run a pilot?
    • Which pilot duration do you consider meaningful for decision-making? Options: 30 days, 60 days, 90 days, Prefer guidance from vendor
    • How many vehicles or customers would you like the pilot to include (select one)? Options: Small sample (10–20 deals), Moderate (21–50 deals), Large (51–100 deals), Open to vendor recommendation
    • What reporting cadence do you want during the pilot to feel informed but not overloaded? Options: Daily digest, Weekly summary, Bi-weekly deep dive, Monthly review
    • If the vendor suggests A/B tests (pricing display, trade messaging, F&I menu order), which areas are you most willing to experiment with? Options: Payment display, Trade valuation messaging, F&I presentation, Appointment scheduling flow, None / conservative

    Show Me the Proof — Monitoring, Acceptance, and Decision Points

    • What is a single, clear acceptance criterion that would make you say ‘pilot succeeded’?
    • Which KPIs must be tracked and reported for acceptance (select all that apply)? Options: Unique digital leads, Digital → showroom conversion, Average time-in-store, F&I penetration per digital deal, Per-deal gross/profit, Customer NPS/CSI
    • Who will review weekly pilot reports and who signs the final acceptance decision? Options: General Manager, Dealer Principal, Group Operations, IT Manager, Internet Sales Manager, Other
    • How would you prefer issues to be raised and resolved during the pilot (channel and escalation path)? Options: Daily Slack/Teams channel, Weekly stand-up call, Email + ticketing system, On-site weekly review, Other
    • If the pilot misses targets but shows promise in one area (e.g., leads up but F&I down), what decision framework should we use?

    Commitment & Next Steps — What's a Realistic Path Forward?

    • Are you willing to commit to a controlled rooftop pilot that may require temporary workflow changes to prove measurable gains? Options: Yes — ready now, Yes — need internal approvals, Maybe — need more info, Not at this time
    • What internal approvals are required (legal, owner, finance) and what is the expected timing for those approvals?
    • Who will be the day-to-day point of contact for coordination, and who is the executive sponsor? Options: Internet Sales Manager, BDC Manager, General Manager, Dealer Principal, IT Manager, Other
    • What are realistic calendar windows for a 2–3 week integration period and a 60–90 day pilot start?
    • What's the single biggest reason you might pause before launching a pilot, and what would remove that barrier?
  2. Solution Experience

    Translate the dealer’s current process into a shared future state by walking a realistic digitally-started deal end-to-end to confirm outcomes and workflow impact.

    Experience Meetings

    • Solution Experience — Prep: Data, Roles & One‑Sentence Current State
    • Current State Mapping Workshop
    • Future State Definition — Outcomes, KPIs & Acceptance
    • Real Deal Walkthrough — Live End‑to‑End (Digitally‑Started Deal)
    • Validation, Pilot Readiness & Pilot Parameters Decision
    • CustomerNode to produce a gap list with owner and ETA for each integration/config issue found during the walkthrough.
    • Present proposed one-sentence Future State
    • Agree a concise Future State sentence that defines the operational improvement.
    • Lock in measurable KPIs and numeric acceptance thresholds for the rooftop pilot.
    • Assign owners for metric collection, reporting, and pilot signoff.
    • Document the Future State sentence and distribute for stakeholder signoff.
    • Finalize KPI definitions, targets, and the pilot acceptance checklist.
    • Assign and confirm the metric owners and schedule the reporting cadence.
    • Recap Current State, Consequence & Future State
    • Demonstrate proof that the platform achieves the defined Future State for at least one live scenario.
    • Obtain explicit validation from dealer SMEs for each step that it addresses the stated problem.
    • Produce a prioritized list of integration/configuration gaps and workflow changes needed for pilot readiness.
    • Introductions & Outcome of this meeting
    • Dealer to confirm any required compensation or workflow policy changes to handle digitally‑started deals.
    • Agree on final platform configuration changes and schedule for implementation before pilot.
    • Review Key Findings & Proof Points
    • Achieve explicit go/no‑go signoff for pilot readiness or a clear remediation plan with dates.
    • Lock the pilot scope, rooftop config, KPI targets, and reporting cadence.
    • Confirm training and change management plan owners and timeline.
    • Finalize and sign the pilot acceptance checklist with named signatories.
    • Schedule the technical integration window (2–3 weeks) and assign technical leads.
    • Set training dates and owner for BDC/sales workflows prior to pilot go‑live.
    • Establish the first pilot performance report date and designated recipients.
    • Produce a clear one-sentence Current State statement signed by dealer SMEs.
    • Document quantified consequence metrics needed for the experience.
    • Obtain commitments for data, test access, and named stakeholders.
    • Agree on 1–3 live deal scenarios to be used in the walkthrough.
    • Dealer to deliver sample DMS/CRM/inventory extracts and historical metrics (conversion, time-in-store, F&I rates).
    • CustomerNode to provide test API access instructions and data format requirements.
    • Named decision owner to confirm acceptance criteria owners and signoff process.
    • Confirm scheduled date/time for the live walkthrough and attendees.
    • Read-back the one-sentence Current State
    • Create a validated, step-by-step current process map with named owners for each step.
    • List top failure modes and attach numeric consequences to each (e.g., X lost deals/month).
    • Identify integration and comp-model constraints that must be respected in the future state.
    • Produce a documented process map and circulate to participants for signoff.
    • Prepare a short list of the top 5 failure modes with supporting metrics.
    • IT to confirm technical constraints (DMS fields, CRM API limits, lender interfaces) in writing.
    • Review Open Gaps, Risks & Mitigations
    • Live Scenario Setup
    • Create the one-sentence Current State
    • Map Future Flow to Eliminate Specific Breakpoints
    • Stepwise Process Walkthrough (Lead → Deal)
    • End‑to‑End Execution — Customer Journey
    • Confirm Pilot Parameters and Acceptance Checklist
    • Identify Breakpoints & Failure Modes
    • Define Pilot KPIs and Numeric Targets
    • Surface the Consequence
    • Acceptance Criteria & Decision Rules
    • Data & Access Checklist
    • Tieback & Validation Pauses
    • Training & Workflow Enablement Plan
    • Quantify Consequences
    • Go/No‑Go Signoff & Next Steps
    • Stakeholder RACI and Decision Criteria
    • Identify Measurement Owners & Reporting Cadence
    • Exercise Exception Paths
    • Integration & Compensation Constraints
    • Capture Configuration Gaps & Workflow Changes
    • Select Live Deal Scenarios & Personas
  3. Solution Scope

    Define modules (search, payment calc, trade, credit app, F&I, desking), integrations, pilot rooftop configuration, roles, and measurable acceptance criteria.

    Scope Configuration

    • DMS Inventory Feed Integration
    • CRM Lead Sync and Field Mapping
    • Lender Rate and Real‑Time Decision Integration
    • Real‑Time Payment Calculator Deployment
    • Trade‑in Valuation Engine Activation
    • Credit Application Soft‑Pull Enablement
    • F&I Menu Mapping and Digital Presentation
    • Online Deal Structuring and Desking Engine
    • Checkout and Reservation (Deposit) Processing
    • Digital Deal Summary and Contract PDF Generation
    • Sales Team Enablement Training for Digital Deals
    • BDC Response Template Deployment
    • Performance Analytics Dashboard Activation
    • A/B Test Variant Deployment for Pricing and UI

    Scope Questions

    DMS Inventory Feed Integration

    • Which DMS vendor(s) do you use on the pilot rooftop? Options: CDK, Dealertrack, Reynolds & Reynolds, Auto/Mate, Other
    • Do you currently expose an inventory feed for third-party integrations? Options: Yes - API (REST/SOAP), Yes - Scheduled CSV/XML export, No, but can enable, No / not available
    • Which inventory fields must be included in the feed (VIN, stock#, price, mileage, photos, options)? List any mandatory fields.
    • What is your required update cadence for inventory (real-time, hourly, daily)? Options: Real-time / push, Every 15 minutes, Hourly, Daily, Other
    • Are photos, option packages, and condition notes available at VIN level in the feed? Options: Yes - full media and options, Partial (photos only), No
    • Who is the technical owner for DMS access and approvals (name/role/contact)?

    CRM Lead Sync and Field Mapping

    • Which CRM(s) will receive leads from the platform on the pilot rooftop? Options: DealerSocket, Dealertrack CRM, VinSolutions, CDK CRM, Other / Custom
    • Do you require real-time lead push (webhook/API) or scheduled batch sync? Options: Real-time push, Near real-time (polling), Scheduled batch (e.g., every 15/60 min), One-time CSV export
    • Which lead fields must be mapped to your CRM (name, phone, email, VIN, offer, payment, lead source)? Specify any required custom fields.
    • What deduplication or lead matching rules should apply (match on phone, email, VIN)? Options: Match by phone, Match by email, Match by VIN, No dedupe - create new lead, Custom rules
    • Do you need lead status/workflow automation created in the CRM (e.g., Digitally Started → Appointment Set)? Options: Yes, No
    • Who will own CRM mapping approvals and testing on the dealer side (name/role)?

    Lender Rate and Real‑Time Decision Integration

    • Which lender types do you want integrated for real-time rates/decisions on pilot (captive, bank, credit union, finance companies)? Options: Captive (e.g., Toyota, Ford), Banks / Finance Companies, Local Credit Unions, Buy Here Pay Here / Subprime, Other
    • Do you require real-time credit decisioning (instant soft pre-qual) or rate lookup only? Options: Real-time decisioning (soft pull), Rate/look-up only, Manual lender submission
    • How are lender integrations currently handled (SFTP, API, portal access, aggregator)? Options: Direct API, Aggregator (e.g., RouteOne), SFTP/Batch, Manual portal access, Unknown
    • What customer data fields will be provided to lenders for decisions (SSN last4, DOB, income, address)?
    • Are there state-specific lender restrictions or compliance requirements we should know about? Options: Yes, No
    • Who signs off on lender integrations and will coordinate test credentials?

    Real‑Time Payment Calculator Deployment

    • Which inputs should the calculator expose to customers (price, tax, fees, trade, down payment, term, APR)? Options: Price, Tax, Dealer Fees, Trade-in, Down Payment, Term, APR/Rate, Rebates/Incentives
    • Should the calculator display multiple payment scenarios (term and down payment variants) or a single recommended payment? Options: Multiple scenarios, Single recommended payment, Both
    • Are there pricing guardrails or minimum margins required to protect profitability? Options: Yes - fixed margin %, Yes - fixed dollar floor, No guardrails
    • Do payments need to match the DMS/desking output exactly for acceptance (tolerance threshold $/%)? Options: Exact match required, Within $10, Within $50, Within %
    • Do you require taxes and registration to be estimated by ZIP code or calculated from DMS? Options: ZIP code estimate, DMS-calculated, Provided by dealer tax table
    • Who will approve payment rule logic and test cases on the dealer side?

    Trade‑in Valuation Engine Activation

    • Do you have a preferred trade valuation provider to activate (KBB, NADA, Black Book, proprietary)? Options: KBB, NADA, Black Book, Proprietary/Dealer appraisal, None - need recommendation
    • Should trade valuation be shown as an instant online estimate, or a conditional offer requiring appraisal? Options: Instant estimate only, Conditional offer requiring appraisal, Instant + conditional appraisal
    • Do you want trade adjustments based on condition or reconditioning costs to be visible to customers? Options: Yes - adjustments visible, Yes - internal only, No
    • Do trade values need to sync to the DMS as pending trades with VIN reference? Options: Yes, No
    • Are photos and vehicle history reports required as part of the trade flow? Options: Yes - photos & history, Photos only, No
    • What acceptance criteria define a successful trade integration (e.g., VIN match rate, valuation variance)?

    Credit Application Soft‑Pull Enablement

    • Will you enable soft-pull prequalification (no hard inquiry) on the pilot? Options: Yes - soft only, Yes - soft then hard with consent, No - full application only
    • Which data fields are required to complete the soft-pull application (SSN last4, full SSN, DOB, income)?
    • Which soft-pull provider or aggregator will be used (RouteOne, Dealertrack, other)? Options: RouteOne, Dealertrack, Aggregator - Other, Direct to lender, Not yet decided
    • What consent and disclosure wording must appear prior to the soft-pull in your state(s)? Options: Use our legal copy, Use platform standard copy, Requires custom legal review
    • What SLA do you require for prequalification responses (seconds, minutes)? Options: <5 seconds, <30 seconds, <5 minutes, No SLA
    • Who will handle privacy/compliance sign-off (legal/GM/IT)?

    F&I Menu Mapping and Digital Presentation

    • Do you have a digital F&I menu file to import (CSV, XML, DMS export)? Options: Yes - CSV/XML, Yes - DMS export, No - need creation
    • Which F&I products must be available by lender or by vehicle (GAP, service contract, appearance, prepaid maintenance)? Options: GAP, Service Contract, Appearance, Prepaid Maintenance, Tire/Wheel, Other
    • Should product pricing be static, percentage-based, or based on lender rules? Options: Static price, Percentage of sale, Lender-specific rules, Hybrid
    • Do you require product descriptions, images, and disclosures visible to consumers? Options: Yes - full descriptions & images, Short descriptions only, No
    • Do F&I selections need to map back to the DMS for contract printing and revenue posting? Options: Yes - full mapping required, Optional mapping, No
    • Who will review and approve the F&I menu mapping and legal disclosures?

    Online Deal Structuring and Desking Engine

    • Which deal types must be supported in desking (cash, finance, lease)? Options: Cash, Finance, Lease
    • What desking rules need to be enforced (reserve, reserve splits, front/back gross, doc fees, incentives)?
    • Does the dealer require overrides, manager approval steps, or audit trails for edits? Options: Manager approval required, Audit trail only, No approval required
    • Should the desk push finalized deals to the DMS with a specific transaction format or fields? Options: Yes - specific DMS mapping, Yes - generic export, No push required
    • Are incentives and manufacturer programs to be applied automatically or manually? Options: Automatic application, Manual selection, Hybrid / conditional
    • What are the acceptance criteria for a successful deal export (field completeness, error rate threshold)?

    Checkout and Reservation (Deposit) Processing

    • Which payment methods should be accepted for deposits (card, ACH, third-party wallets)? Options: Credit/Debit Card, ACH, PayPal/Wallet, Other
    • Do you have a preferred payment gateway or merchant account? Options: Stripe, Adyen, Authorize.net, Vantiv/Worldpay, Use dealer processor, Need recommendation
    • What deposit/refund policy should be enforced (amount, refundable/non-refundable, timeout)?
    • Is PCI compliance handled by the dealer or should the platform manage tokenization? Options: Dealer handles PCI, Platform handles tokenization, Unsure
    • Do you require invoice/receipt generation tied to deposit transactions and stored in DMS/CRM? Options: Yes - store in DMS, Yes - store in CRM, No
    • Who will provide merchant account credentials and sign documentation for payment processing?

    Digital Deal Summary and Contract PDF Generation

    • Do you require templated deal summaries and fully populated contract PDFs per state? Options: Yes - state-specific templates, Yes - generic template, No
    • Which e-signature provider do you prefer (DocuSign, AdobeSign, other) or will you use DMS signing? Options: DocuSign, AdobeSign, DMS e-sign, Other, No e-signature
    • Should generated PDFs be stored back into the DMS, CRM, and platform records? Options: DMS, CRM, Platform only, All three
    • Are there specific disclosures or state-required language that must be included in the PDF? Options: Yes - provide text, No - use platform defaults
    • What acceptance criteria define a correct contract PDF (field completeness, legal sign-off)?
    • Who will approve contract templates and coordinate e-signature testing?
  4. Mutual Commit

    Agree pilot length, commercial terms, data/access commitments, success metrics, and decision criteria for broader rollout.

    Agreement Modules

    • Non-Disclosure Agreement (NDA)
    • Statement of Work (SOW)
    • Pilot Agreement / Addendum
    • Commercial Terms & Pricing Schedule
    • Data Processing & Access Agreement (DPA)
    • Integration & Technical Access Authorization
    • Success Metrics & Acceptance Criteria Annex
    • Pilot Governance & Escalation Plan
    • Sales Compensation & Workflow Impact Agreement
    • Change Order & Scope Modification
    • Termination & Exit Plan
    • Billing Authorization & Payment Method
    • Publicity & Reference Consent
  5. Deployment

    Operationalize rollout with readiness checks, enablement, and outcome validation.

    1. Pre-Deployment Readiness

      Confirm technical access, data mappings (DMS, inventory, lenders, F&I menu), owners, and risk controls required for integration and pilot execution.

      Readiness Questions

      What’s Driving This Change?

      • What’s the main reason you’re exploring an online retailing platform right now? Options: Increase unique leads, Improve digital-to-showroom conversion, Reduce time-in-store, Modernize customer experience, Respond to competitors, Reduce sales cycle time, Other
      • How long have you been considering a digital retailing solution for this rooftop or group? Options: Just started this week, A few weeks, 1–3 months, 3–6 months, Longer than 6 months
      • Which digital capabilities do you already have in place today? Options: Website only (lead form), Online trade valuation, Basic payment calculator, Credit application (paper/phone), Partial integration with CRM/DMS, Full digital retailing on another rooftop, None
      • Tell us the most recent example where a digital change at your store clearly helped or hurt sales—what happened?
      • If this pilot delivered no new customers but made in-store interactions shorter and smoother, how would you feel about that outcome? Options: Very positive, Cautiously positive, Neutral, Disappointed

      Are We Just Moving Leads, Not Sales?

      • What if this platform simply reroutes existing showroom shoppers into a different queue—would that be a win or a problem for you? Options: Clear win, Problematic (cannibalizes walk-ins), Depends on profitability per deal, Unsure
      • What evidence have you seen that digital channels are bringing truly incremental customers versus shifting existing traffic?
      • Which of these metrics do you currently track to assess channel incrementality? Options: Unique leads, Digital-to-showroom conversion, Sales uplift by channel, Average time-in-store, F&I attach rate on digital deals, We don’t have a measurement set
      • What minimum uplift in incremental sales would make a pilot successful for you (even if profitability per deal changes)? Options: >20%, 10–20%, 5–10%, 1–5%, No uplift needed if efficiency improves, Unsure
      • Can you share an example where a new customer channel looked promising initially but didn’t deliver—what did you learn?

      Who’s Steering This Ship — Who’s Actually Accountable?

      • If the GM says 'go' but IT says 'no', who ultimately makes the call for this rooftop? Options: Dealer Principal / GM, IT / Network Admin, Internet Sales / BDC Manager, Controller/Finance, Collective decision, Undecided
      • Which roles must be actively involved in the pilot (pick all that apply)? Options: Dealer Principal, General Manager, Internet Sales / BDC Manager, Sales Managers, F&I Manager, Controller / Finance, IT / Network Admin, DMS vendor representative, CRM vendor representative, Other
      • Who will be the day-to-day owner for pilot operations at the rooftop (title/name)?
      • How do you prefer decisions to be made during the pilot—consensus, GM sign-off, or pre-assigned owner? Options: GM sign-off, Pre-assigned owner, Consensus among stakeholders, Escalate to group level
      • Have you run a 60–90 day pilot like this before? If yes, what was the cadence and who signed off at the end?

      Integration Nightmares or Smooth Sailing?

      • If your DMS or CRM can’t share clean, mapped data, is a 2–3 week integration realistic or fantasy? Options: Realistic, Likely challenging, Impossible without changes, Unsure—need to check
      • Which DMS and CRM systems are in use at this rooftop (select all that apply)? Options: CDK, Dealertrack/DMS, Reynolds & Reynolds, DealerBuilt, Auto/Mate, Cox Automotive (vAuto), VinSolutions/CRM, Elead/CRM, Other
      • How is your inventory currently delivered to external tools? Options: API from DMS, Third-party aggregator feed, Daily CSV/flat file, Manual upload, No automated feed
      • What lender integrations do you already have or plan to require (name lenders or networks)?
      • How is your F&I product menu currently managed and where is it stored? Options: Digital menu in DMS, Third-party F&I menu vendor, Paper/manual menu, Not standardized, Other
      • Do you have a sandbox/test environment and credentials available for the DMS, inventory feed, and lender APIs? Options: Full sandbox available, Partial test access, Only live credentials, No test environment
      • Are there firewall, VPN, or vendor approval steps that typically delay integrations at this rooftop? If so, describe.

      Money, Compensation, and Team Feelings

      • Would your sales or BDC teams feel threatened if more of the deal was structured before showroom interaction? Options: Yes — they'd feel threatened, No — they'd welcome the efficiency, Mixed feelings across teams, We haven’t asked them yet
      • How are your sales and internet teams currently compensated (select all that apply)? Options: Flat commission per sale, Gross per unit (GPU) model, Split commission between BDC and sale, Salary + performance bonus, No formal commission structure, Other
      • Would you consider adjusted compensation for digitally-started deals (e.g., fixed fee for BDC, different GPU)? Options: Yes — already planned, Yes — open to discuss, Prefer no change, Unsure
      • What are your expectations for F&I penetration on digitally-started deals versus walk-ins? Options: Match in-store rates, Slight decrease acceptable, Expect equal or higher, Unsure / need to measure
      • What internal training bandwidth exists to onboard sales and BDC for the pilot (hours per week or resources)? Options: Dedicated trainer available, Limited time from managers, No bandwidth—need vendor-led training, We’ll need a phased approach
      • How would you communicate and manage team sentiment about this change—formal meeting, town hall, 1:1s, or another approach? Options: Formal meeting, Town hall, Manager 1:1s, Email + training, Combination, Other

      Pilot Success — What Would Make This Worthwhile?

      • If after 90 days you could only show one metric to greenlight rollout, which single figure would convince you? Options: Unique incremental sales, Digital-to-showroom conversion rate, Gross profit per deal uplift, Reduction in average time-in-store, F&I attach rate on digital deals, Other
      • What target number of unique incremental leads over 60–90 days would you consider a success?
      • What is the minimum acceptable digital-to-showroom conversion percentage for the pilot to be considered promising? Options: >40%, 25–40%, 15–25%, <15%, Unsure—need modeling
      • How much reduction in average customer time-in-store would be meaningful to you? Options: >40% reduction, 20–40% reduction, 10–20% reduction, Any reduction is good
      • Beyond raw metrics, what qualitative signals would make you feel confident about rolling out (examples: staff adoption, customer NPS, reduced paperwork)?
      • What is your acceptable ROI timeline after rollout (months to break-even)? Options: <6 months, 6–12 months, 12–24 months, Longer than 24 months, Unsure

      What Could Go Wrong — And Who’s Responsible?

      • What’s the single failure scenario that would make you pull the plug during or immediately after the pilot? Options: Integration failure (data mismatch), Sales adoption near zero, Severe negative customer feedback, F&I revenue collapse, Compliance/regulatory issue, Other
      • Who will own technical incidents during the pilot (internal role and backup)?
      • What escalation path and SLA expectations do you require for critical issues during the pilot? Options: Immediate 24/7 support, Business hours support with 4-hour response, Next-business-day response, Custom SLA—define below
      • Which risk controls are mandatory before we can go live (select all that apply)? Options: Data masking / PII minimization, Audit logs for deal changes, Two-stage deal acceptance, Role-based access controls, Vendor background checks / security review, Other
      • Are there contractual or compliance approvals needed from your side (legal, finance, insurance) before a pilot can start? Options: Signed MSA/contract, PO required, Insurance certificates, Data processing addendum, No approvals needed
      • What level of outage or data error tolerance can you accept during the pilot? Options: No outages tolerated, <1 hour/day with notice, <4 hours/week, Acceptable with prior notice

      Can We Move Fast Without Tripping? — Planning the First 30 Days

      • Could your team commit to a contiguous 2–3 week technical integration window followed by a monitored pilot period? Options: Yes, ready now, Yes, with limited resources, Not within 30 days, Need more planning
      • Which internal resources will be available during the integration (list titles or names)?
      • What is your preferred target start window for the pilot? Options: Within 2 weeks, Within 1 month, 1–3 months, 3+ months, Dependent on approvals
      • What reporting cadence would you like during the pilot to feel informed but not overwhelmed? Options: Weekly short check-ins + dashboard, Bi-weekly detailed review, Monthly executive summary, Ad-hoc on major events
      • Who should be added to the shared pilot communication channel (names/titles) and what is your preferred channel (Slack, Teams, email)? Options: Slack, Microsoft Teams, Email thread, Other
      • Are there any outstanding budget, contract, or approval items we should resolve before scheduling work (please describe)?
    2. Deployment Enablement

      Execute integrations, configure pricing/desking rules, train BDC and sales workflows, and schedule the 2–3 week technical work followed by pilot go‑live.

    3. Pilot Validation Checklist

      Verify data flows, tracking of target metrics, reporting cadence, and acceptance criteria during the 60–90 day rooftop pilot to inform roll/no-roll decisions.

      Validation Questions

      Start Here — A Quick Snapshot of Your Role

      • Which of the following best describes your role today? Options: Dealer Principal/Owner, General Manager, Marketing Director, Internet Sales Manager/BDC Lead, Controller/Finance, IT/Systems Admin, Other
      • How many rooftops and total rooftops does your group operate (or is this a single rooftop)? Options: Single rooftop, 2–5 rooftops, 6–20 rooftops, 21+ rooftops
      • Roughly what share of your retail vehicle inquiries today begin online (lead form, Chat, digital app, etc.)? Options: <10%, 10–25%, 26–50%, 51–75%, 76–100%, Unsure
      • When a deal is started online today, whose workflow owns it once the customer arrives at the dealership? Options: BDC/Internet Sales, Floor Salesperson, Sales Manager, Finance Manager, Hybrid/Varies by store, No clear owner
      • Tell us one recent win or moment that makes you optimistic about your current online-to-in-store process.

      Are You Moving Market Share—or Just Moving Customers Around?

      • What evidence makes you believe digital retailing will create net-new sales instead of just shifting your existing showroom traffic?
      • Compared to walk-ins, how do you expect leads started digitally to perform on these metrics? Options: Higher close rate, Similar close rate, Lower close rate, Unsure
      • Have you ever run an experiment or pilot aimed specifically at proving incremental sales from online tools? If yes, what did you learn? Options: Yes—clear uplift, Yes—no clear change, Yes—inconclusive, No, never
      • What would feel like convincing proof that the platform is generating net-new business for your rooftop? Options: % increase in unique leads, Increase in closed deals attributed to digital starts, Higher sell-through per month, More first-contact appointments, Other
      • Who internally will push back most if the platform appears to cannibalize floor traffic, and why?

      Where the Customer Journey Breaks — What Actually Frustrates You?

      • What is the single biggest pain point when customers start a deal online and then show up in person?
      • At which stage do you see the highest drop-off: initial search, trade valuation, payment calc, credit app, or desking/F&I? Options: Search/vehicle selection, Trade valuation, Payment calculator, Credit application, Desking/F&I, Other/varies
      • How long does a typical digitally-started customer spend in the showroom today (estimate in minutes)? Options: <15 min, 15–30 min, 31–60 min, 61–120 min, 120+ min, Don't track
      • Where do your teams most commonly lose momentum—BDC handoff, sales follow-up, F&I alignment, lender response time, or something else? Options: BDC handoff, Sales follow-up, F&I alignment, Lender decisioning, Inventory mismatches, Customer finance expectations, Other
      • Share an example of a recent digitally-started deal that went sideways—what happened and how did it feel for the customer and your team?

      Who’s In The Room — Champions, Skeptics, and Quiet Blockers

      • If we brought this pilot to your rooftop for 60–90 days, whose explicit approval would we need to start (select all that apply)? Options: Dealer Principal/Owner, General Manager, Controller/Finance, Sales Manager, Internet Sales Manager/BDC Lead, IT/Systems Admin, F&I Manager, Service Manager, Other
      • Who will be the final decision-maker on whether to expand beyond the pilot? Options: Dealer Principal/Owner, General Manager, Regional/Group Exec, Board/Investor, Other
      • Who on your team is most likely to push back on rollout because of compensation structure or perceived threat to commissions? Options: Sales Manager, Sales Team, F&I Manager, BDC/Internet Team, None, Unsure
      • How would you describe the general attitude of your salesfloor toward digital tools that change in-store workflow? Options: Eager/adopters, Cautiously open, Resistant/defensive, Mixed across individuals, No clear opinion
      • What internal change management resources can we rely on (training time, coaching, role champions)? Options: Dedicated trainer, Sales manager-led training, Online modules only, No dedicated resource, Other

      The Tech Reality Check — Integrations, Data, and Access

      • Which DMS(s) and CRM(s) does this rooftop use? Options: CDK, Dealertrack, Reynolds & Reynolds, Autosoft, DealerSocket, VinSolutions, Other, Unsure
      • Do you have API access or a middleware partner for DMS/CRM connections today? Options: Direct API access, Middleware partner (e.g., CDK Connect), SFTP/flat files only, No integration capability, Unsure
      • What lender connectivity exists today for real-time rate/decisioning—single lenders, dealer networks, or manual submissions? Options: Multiple integrated lenders, Single lender integration, Lender portal manual, Dealer network integration, No lender integration, Unsure
      • What are the non-negotiable data fields or feeds we must map for you to accept a pilot (select all that apply)? Options: Inventory VIN/price, Payoff/loan info, Customer data (name/contact), Credit decisioning, F&I product menu/pricing, Desking rules and margins, Compensation reports, Other
      • How do you currently verify data integrity between systems—manual checks, nightly syncs, or automated reconciliation? Options: Automated reconciliation, Nightly batch syncs, Manual spot checks, No formal process, Other
      • Are there legal/privacy or lender-specific approvals required before we can send customer data during a pilot? Options: Yes—must sign agreements, Yes—lender approvals only, No special approvals, Unsure

      What Would Success Actually Look Like — Beyond Vanity Metrics

      • If the pilot is wildly successful, what three measurable outcomes would you point to when reporting to the owner/board?
      • Which of these metrics matter most to your leadership when evaluating a pilot? Options: Unique digital leads, Digital-to-showroom conversion, Close rate of digitally-started deals, Average time-in-store reduction, F&I penetration on digital deals, Gross per deal, Customer satisfaction/CSAT
      • What is your current baseline for unique digital leads per month (estimate)? Options: <10, 10–25, 26–50, 51–100, 101–250, 250+
      • What percentage uplift in those key metrics would make you comfortable recommending a roll? Options: 5–10%, 11–20%, 21–40%, 40%+, No specific target—need statistical significance
      • How will you determine whether gains are causally tied to the platform versus market or OEM promotions? Options: Control rooftop/store comparison, Time-based baseline comparison, Attribution via CRM tagging, Other methods, No plan yet

      Designing a Pilot That Actually Answers the Question

      • Would you be willing to run a 60–90 day rooftop pilot with agreed tracking, or do you prefer a shorter/longer test? Options: 60 days, 90 days, Shorter (30–45 days), Longer (120+ days), Unsure—need to discuss
      • Which rooftop configuration would give you the cleanest signal: single-store pilot, matched-pair stores, or phased multi-store? Options: Single-store pilot, Matched-pair (control + test), Phased rollout across multiple stores, Group-wide pilot
      • What minimum sample size (unique digital leads or completed digital deals) would make the pilot results statistically credible to you? Options: <50 leads, 50–100 leads, 101–250 leads, 251–500 leads, 500+ leads, Unsure—need vendor input
      • Who will own daily operations and troubleshooting during the pilot (names/titles)?
      • What cadence and format do you want for pilot reporting (weekly dashboard, bi-weekly review, live access to analytics)? Options: Weekly dashboard + weekly call, Bi-weekly review call, Live dashboard access only, Monthly executive summary, Ad-hoc updates

      Money, Margins, and Motivations — The Financial Conversation

      • How are you most concerned the platform could affect per-deal economics (check all that apply)? Options: Lower F&I penetration, Compression of gross margins, Higher per-deal costs (fees/subscription), Improved gross via better structured deals, No material effect
      • What is an acceptable monthly or per-deal cost structure for a pilot to make the economics palatable? Options: Paid pilot (monthly fee), Revenue-share per completed deal, Per-lead fee, No cost pilot (vendor-funded), Other
      • Would you accept temporary adjustments to compensation plans for digitally-started deals during the pilot (e.g., guaranteed split, bonus for digital closes)? Options: Yes—open to adjustments, Yes—but limited, Unlikely without owner sign-off, No
      • How sensitive would leadership be to an initial dip in F&I penetration if total closed deals and gross dollars rose? Options: Very tolerant, Somewhat tolerant, Not tolerant, Depends on magnitude
      • What financial reports or P&L views do you need to evaluate pilot profitability? Options: Per-deal gross breakdown, F&I attach rates, Sales commission impact, Overall store P&L, Customer lifetime value estimate, Other

      Risks, Compliance, and Customer Experience Concerns

      • What are your top three compliance, legal, or privacy concerns about moving more of the deal online?
      • Have lenders or compliance teams ever rejected digital signatures/data transfer methods in your experience? Options: Yes—frequently, Occasionally, Rarely, Never, Unsure
      • How important is maintaining a consistent CX between digital and showroom (e.g., same F&I offers, same price transparency)? Options: Critical, Very important, Somewhat important, Not a priority
      • What customer segments do you worry might be alienated by a more digital-first experience? Options: Older customers, Luxury buyers, Lease customers, Trade-in heavy buyers, All segments, No one
      • If a negative customer experience happened during the pilot, what escalation path should we use? Options: Sales Manager, GM/DP, Customer Experience Lead, Vendor success manager, Other

      What Would Make You Confident to Move Fast?

      • If we could guarantee one thing at pilot start, what guarantee would change your openness the most (data security, no-cost pilot, guaranteed uplift, training support)? Options: Data security & privacy, No-cost pilot, Uplift guarantee, Dedicated training & onsite support, Other
      • What minimum documentation or artifacts do you need before signing a pilot (SOW, data flow diagrams, security assessment, commercial terms)? Options: SOW, Data flow diagrams, Security/privacy assessment, Commercial terms, Integration plan, Other
      • What timeline would you be comfortable with from agreement to go‑live, assuming integrations are straightforward? Options: 1–2 weeks, 2–3 weeks, 4–6 weeks, 6+ weeks, Depends on integrations
      • What would you want to see in week 1, week 3, and week 8 of the pilot to feel it’s on track?

      Commitments and Next Steps — Who Does What, When

      • Who will be our primary point(s) of contact and their preferred communication method (email, Slack, phone)?
      • What internal approvals or signatures are needed before we can begin technical access? Options: IT approval, Owner/GM sign-off, Lender approvals, Finance/Controller sign-off, No approvals required, Other
      • Are there blackout dates or peak sales periods when we should not run a pilot? Options: Yes—list dates, No
      • What would a ‘go/no-go’ decision look like at pilot end—who signs it off and what docs are required?
      • Is there anything else we haven’t asked that you think will make or break a successful pilot?
  6. Success

    Review pilot performance against agreed metrics, capture learnings, and maintain a shared channel for issues and enhancement requests to drive broader rollout.

    Success Reviews

    • Pilot Performance Review — Executive
    • Operational Validation — Sales & BDC
    • Technical & Data Review — IT & Integrations
    • Learnings & Enhancements Workshop — Product, Ops & Customer
    • Rollout Planning & Commercial Agreement

    Issues & Enhancements

    • Create the prioritized enhancement backlog in the agreed tracking channel and assign owners and target dates.
    • Confirm that the digitally‑started deal workflow delivers the intended future state in practice, not just in theory.
    • Surface and document operational gaps and immediate process changes required before rollout.
    • Assign owners and schedule training to address identified skill or script gaps.
    • Update BDC and sales scripts and handoff checklist to reflect validated process changes.
    • Schedule and run a role‑play training session for BDC and sales within two weeks.
    • Document 3 representative pilot deals as case studies for onboarding/training materials.
    • Current Integration Health Snapshot
    • Confirm technical readiness and data integrity for scaling beyond the pilot or define required fixes before rollout.
    • Agree on prioritized defect list, owners, and SLAs for remediation with clear timelines.
    • Validate tracking and attribution so leadership can trust the reported pilot metrics.
    • Create a prioritized technical defect list with owners, target fix dates, and verification steps.
    • Implement analytics event fixes and run an integrity check on historical pilot data.
    • Schedule a technical re‑signoff meeting after fixes are completed (target within 2 weeks).
    • Synthesis of Top Pilot Learnings
    • Capture a complete, prioritized enhancement backlog with acceptance criteria and owners.
    • Agree on a shared channel and governance for issues and enhancement requests to enable transparent tracking.
    • Define validation plans so each change has measurable success criteria post‑release.
    • Opening & Objectives
    • Set up the shared communication channel and the triage cadence (weekly or biweekly).
    • Draft A/B test plans or pilot extension scopes for the top 2 enhancements and schedule execution.
    • Confirm Decision Rationale
    • Secure agreement on commercial terms and the phased rollout plan aligned to pilot learnings.
    • Confirm resource commitments, training plan, and support model for the rollout.
    • Document risk mitigations and assign owners for each identified risk area.
    • Execute contract amendment or PO reflecting agreed commercial terms and pilot credits, if any.
    • Publish a detailed rollout schedule with wave owners, technical windows, and training dates.
    • Create a launch playbook that includes rollback criteria, escalation paths, and a 30/60/90 day post‑roll metrics review cadence.
    • Ensure executive alignment on whether pilot results meet the agreed success criteria and business expectations.
    • Secure a clear decision (rollout, extend, or iterate) with named owners and timeline.
    • Surface any commercial or compensation issues that must be resolved before rollout.
    • Produce a one‑page executive summary with KPIs, financial impact, and recommended decision for distribution to stakeholders.
    • If approved to roll, issue a target rollout timeline and assign a rollout lead and executive sponsor.
    • If conditional or pause decision, list gating requirements and deadlines for follow-up decision.
    • Pre‑work & Expectations
    • Data Flow Verification (DMS, Inventory, CRM, Lenders, F&I Menu)
    • One‑Sentence Current Operational State
    • Commercial Terms & Pricing Adjustments
    • Capture & Clarify Enhancement Requests
    • One‑Sentence Current State (Pilot Summary)
    • Prioritization Exercise (Impact / Cost / Urgency)
    • Rollout Phasing & Timeline
    • Metrics Dashboard Walkthrough
    • Live Walkthrough: Representative Digitally‑Started Deal(s)
    • Error Log & Incident Triage
    • Consequence & ROI Analysis
    • Analytics, Attribution & Event Tracking
    • Define Success Criteria & Validation Plan for Top Items
    • Metrics by Workflow & Handoff Quality
    • Resource, Training & Support Plan
    • Security, Access, & Risk Controls
    • Frontline Feedback & Customer Sentiment
    • Risk Mitigation & Change Management
    • Shared Channel & Governance Setup
    • Future State Recommendation
    • Decision & Criteria Confirmation
    • Fix Plan, Ownership & SLA
    • Release & Testing Schedule
    • Issues, Workarounds, and Quick Wins
    • Sign‑offs, Contracting & Next Milestones
First-Party AI

1-2 minutes please — Your AI agent is working

First-Party AI™ can make mistakes. Always check important information.