Wind Energy Development
Long-cycle programs where regulation, capital, and grid reliability define the pace.
Inside this journey
-
Pre-Discovery
Align decision-makers, approval gates, and regulatory constraints before technical discovery.
-
Stakeholder Alignment
Confirm decision roles, approval gates, timeline, and key commercial and regulatory constraints across procurement, finance, and the board.
Alignment Questions
Opening: Your Energy Ambition (Easy Start)
- What's your primary reason for exploring wind energy right now?
- How soon do you need a commercial decision or go/no-go on this opportunity?
- Which internal teams are directly involved in evaluating this project today?
- Do you already have a target LCOE, PPA price, or capital budget range in mind?
- If you indicated a target, please state the LCOE, PPA range, or budget assumptions and how firm that target is.
- When you talk internally about pursuing wind, what emotions or attitudes show up most often?
What Would Break the Status Quo?
- If this project stalls over the next 12–24 months, what concrete risks or costs will your organization face?
- Which outcomes are absolutely unacceptable to let slide (e.g., missed capacity targets, regulatory fines, credit rating impact)?
- How often have comparable projects in your portfolio missed their original milestones?
- Who in your organization has previously lost patience with slow projects—and can you share a brief example?
- Which internal policies or procurement rules usually add the longest delays?
- How willing is senior leadership to accept schedule or execution risk to accelerate delivery?
Hidden Roadblocks — Where Projects Quietly Stall
- What procedural or political hurdle do you privately fear will stop this project?
- Where does the project currently sit in the permitting and approvals pipeline?
- What best describes your interconnection status and expected timeline to an executed agreement?
- Have you encountered community, landowner, or stakeholder opposition in past projects here?
- If opposition or delays occurred, what were the top causes and how were they usually resolved?
- Which supply-chain elements worry you most for delivery timing (select all that apply)?
- How do these operational or political risks make your stakeholders feel—frustrated, cautious, resigned, or something else?
Decisions, Dollars, and Deadlines — Who Signs and When?
- Is the person leading this engagement authorized to sign the final commercial documents, or will the decision escalate—and how will that change timing?
- Which roles must sign off on the final commercial terms?
- Please list the formal approval gates and typical cadences (e.g., monthly finance committee, quarterly board).
- Will a financing condition precedent (debt commitment, tax equity, letter of credit) be required before execution?
- How many reviewers typically redline contracts in your organization before execution?
- What worries stakeholders most when contemplating signing a long-term energy agreement?
What 'Good Enough' Looks Like — Outcomes and Non-Negotiables
- If you could lock a single success metric for this project, which would it be?
- Please specify measurable acceptance criteria you need (target LCOE or PPA $/MWh, minimum availability %, guaranteed annual generation).
- What minimum availability over the first five years is acceptable to your stakeholders?
- How much year-to-year production variability are you prepared to tolerate without financial remediation?
- Which risk allocations are non‑negotiable for you (select all that apply)?
- If acceptance criteria are not met, what remedies or escalation paths would satisfy your organization?
Site & Grid Reality Check
- What single unknown about the site or grid makes you least comfortable committing capital?
- Has an independent wind resource assessment and validation been completed?
- What is the current status of land rights and lease agreements for the site?
- Have environmental baseline studies (avian, habitat, noise) and mitigation plans been completed?
- What substation or evacuation upgrades are expected and who is expected to fund them?
- Do you have historical transmission curtailment or congestion at the targeted interconnection?
- What evidence or steps would materially increase your confidence in site and grid readiness?
Commercial Structure — Are We Aligned on Risk and Reward?
- If your CFO could rewrite the commercial deal tomorrow, what single change would they insist on?
- Which commercial structure do you prefer for this project?
- What contract length are you targeting for the offtake or revenue stream?
- Which price indexation approaches are acceptable to you?
- What forms of credit support or guarantees can you provide or expect from partners?
- Would you be open to a staged commercial approach (pilot phase, then scale) to de-risk execution?
Execution Confidence — Can You Live With Our Track Record?
- When you hear an OEM or developer claim 97%+ availability, what would make you doubt that number?
- Which types of proof would you want to see to validate operational performance?
- How important is a site visit to an operating fleet before you award supply or services?
- What maximum supply-chain lead times are acceptable for turbines and major components?
- Describe any prior supplier failures or delivery issues you've experienced and the business impact.
- Which performance remedy structure would feel most balanced to you?
Finance & Contracting Redlines — What's Non-Negotiable?
- Which contractual clause would cause your board, lender, or insurer to reject the deal outright?
- Which contract elements do you routinely push back on during negotiation?
- What insurance types and limits will you require for construction and operations?
- What timeline do you need for legal review and closing (from first draft to signature)?
- Which financial milestones must align with contract signature (select all that apply)?
- Are there regulatory approvals that, if not obtained, would invalidate or materially change the contract?
Next Steps & Commitment — What Would Make This Easy to Say Yes To?
- If we could give you two tangible commitments today, which specific commitments would move you to a clear 'yes'?
- Which of these commitments would be most persuasive (select up to three)?
- What is the single next action we should take to increase your internal momentum?
- Who must be present in the next meeting and what evidence will each person need to see to move forward?
-
Current State Mapping
Document existing resource assessments, interconnection queue position, permitting status, and supplier/contract exposure that inform risk and schedule.
Current State
Tell Us About Your Project — The short version that gets everyone on the same page
- What best describes this opportunity?
- What is the project name or internal reference we should use?
- Where is the project located (primary county / region and grid/interconnect node)?
- Planned capacity (MW) and single-turbine size preference if known
- Target commercial operation date (COD) or desired in-service year
Is the Interconnection Really as Safe as You Think?
- What is your current interconnection queue position and the queue name/ID?
- Which study or milestone is the project currently in?
- What COD window did you list in the queue, and how flexible is that date?
- If the interconnection slips 6–18 months, what are the concrete commercial or regulatory consequences you're most concerned about?
- Have you identified mitigation levers (e.g., alternate substations, DER/curtailment strategies, or staged COD) and who would own them?
What’s Actually Driving Your Energy Forecasts?
- Are your energy estimates based on measured on-site data, hub-height remote sensing, or modeled data only?
- What statistical confidence metrics do you use and target (e.g., P50/P90) for lender and offtaker approvals?
- Which aerodynamic / windfarm models and software were used for the energy estimate (e.g., WAsP, WindPro, OpenFAST, CFD)?
- Have wake losses, terrain complexity, and micrositing uncertainty been quantified separately? If so, how were these validated?
- How long have you been collecting site data and what gaps remain that could materially change AEP or P50/P90?
- Would you be open to an independent third-party resource reanalysis to tighten P90 certainty for lenders/offtakers?
Could Permitting or Local Opposition Stop This Project Cold?
- Which key permits and approvals do you already hold, and which remain outstanding?
- Has the project faced community opposition, legal challenges, or prior permit denials—how recent and what was the outcome?
- Are there known environmental or species risks (e.g., raptor corridors, wetlands) that require mitigation plans?
- What is your expected timeline for all local/state/federal approvals, and which approvals are the critical path?
- Who in your organization is driving permitting and community engagement, and do they have escalation authority when timelines slip?
Who’s Really Committed on Supply — and Who Might Walk Away?
- Do you have executed turbine supply agreements (TSAs) or binding letters of intent? If yes, which items are firm (slot, price, delivery window)?
- What are the currently promised turbine lead times (months from PO to delivery) and how sensitive is your schedule to a ±3–6 month shift?
- Have you secured logistics (port access, heavy-lift windows, road upgrades) and who bears those costs/risks?
- Have contract clauses been discussed for supply disruption (force majeure, supplier insolvency, allocation, substitution) and are there performance bonds or penalties?
- If your primary supplier cannot deliver, what is the practical backup (alternate OEM, delayed COD, reduced scope)?
Who Carries the Biggest Contractual Risk — You, the Offtaker, or the Lender?
- Which commercial model are you planning to use for this deal?
- What offtake or revenue certainty is required by your financiers or board (e.g., long-term PPA length, minimum credit rating)?
- How are schedule risks allocated in your current term-sheet—are liquidated damages, extension windows, or contractor incentives defined?
- What security instruments are expected or in place (parent guarantees, completion bonds, letter of credit)?
- If a key milestone is missed (e.g., interconnection date), what are the immediate contractual remedies or escalation steps you expect?
What Happens If the Schedule Starts to Slip — Do You Have a Contingency Play?
- Do you hold contingency budget and timeline buffers; if so, what percent of capex and what month buffer do you carry?
- Who is the named escalation owner for schedule or supplier crises, and do they have authority to make trade-offs (scope vs. time vs. cost)?
- Which of these acceleration levers would you be willing to deploy if needed (select all that apply)?
- Have financing covenants been stress-tested against a 6–12 month schedule slip, and what lender remedies would be triggered?
- What’s the single contingency you don’t have yet but believe would materially reduce execution risk?
How Much Certainty Do You Need to Say Yes?
- What minimum availability guarantee do your stakeholders require (select single target or range)?
- What is the LCOE or PPA price target range that will make this economically viable for your organization?
- How much energy uncertainty (e.g., tolerance for P90 shortfall) can your finance team accept without re-pricing?
- Which guarantees or financial instruments would you require from an OEM/developer (availability guarantees, availability-linked payments, liquidated damages, performance bonds)?
- Are there internal metrics or board-level KPIs that would block go/no-go if not met (e.g., IRR threshold, debt coverage ratio, emissions targets)? Please list the top 2–3.
Before We Move Forward — What Would Give You Real Confidence?
- Which deliverable from a developer/OEM would increase your confidence most right now?
- What timeline would feel realistic and acceptable for receiving those deliverables?
- Who are the internal stakeholders we should engage next (titles/roles) and what decision authority do they each hold?
- If we identify a single critical unknown that could derail your schedule, what decision would you want within 2 weeks to prevent it?
- Finally, what would you most like us to solve or take off your plate in the next 30 days to move this opportunity forward?
-
-
Outcome Discovery
Define the customer’s target outcomes, acceptance criteria (LCOE, availability, energy certainty), and non-negotiable risk tolerances.
Discovery Questions
A Quick Intro — Who Are We Talking With?
- Who is completing this discovery on behalf of your organization, and what is your role in the project?
- Project name or internal identifier (if available)
- What is the single biggest objective you need this wind project to deliver?
- Who else on your team is critical to this decision (names/titles) and how would you like us to engage them?
- What is your preferred method for receiving updates and technical evidence (e.g., weekly deck, SCADA access, live model)?
Are We Aiming to Play Small or Move the Needle?
- If you had to characterize your ambition for this asset — are you optimizing for scale, certainty, speed, or lowest cost?
- What is your target nameplate capacity for this phase?
- What commercial structure are you currently favoring for this project?
- How fixed is your preferred structure — are you open to alternative structures if they materially improve LCOE or schedule?
- What is your target Commercial COD window?
What Does 'Winning' Look Like When the Turbines Spin?
- When you picture the first year of operation, what outcome would make you say this project succeeded?
- What is your target LCOE range that would allow you to proceed?
- What minimum long-run availability (fleet-level) do you require?
- How do you define energy certainty for contractual commitments (e.g., P90/P95/P99 or another metric)?
- How important is production vs. price trade-off for you (rank priority): price stability or production certainty?
- Tell us about a past procurement where the operational outcomes matched (or failed) your expectations — what happened and why?
Which Risks Actually Drive Your Decisions (and Your Worries)?
- Which of the following risks keep you or your board awake at night for this project?
- Which of those risks have you experienced directly on past projects? Please describe the impact.
- How much schedule delay (months) can your stakeholders tolerate before it meaningfully threatens the project?
- What level of contingency budget (as % of EPC) is acceptable to your finance team?
- If a major risk materializes (e.g., interconnection delay), how would your organization prefer to resolve it—absorb, share, or transfer?
What Would You Never, Ever Compromise?
- Select the items you consider absolute deal-breakers for this project
- Please specify numeric thresholds for any deal-breakers you selected (e.g., max LCOE, min availability, required credit rating)
- Are there regulatory or board-level constraints that create hard limits we must design around?
- If we proposed a solution that met most goals but crossed one of your non-negotiables, how would you expect that to be handled?
- Briefly describe any political, community or stakeholder constraints that are effectively non-negotiable
If We Could Guarantee One Thing — What Moves the Needle?
- Which single guarantee would make you most comfortable signing (pick one)?
- What kind of evidence would you need to trust that guarantee (third-party validation, historical fleet data, escrowed penalties)?
- What forms of remedies or penalties against under-performance feel acceptable to your legal/finance teams?
- How important is it that guarantees are bankable (i.e., acceptable to lenders and insurers)?
Numbers, Data, and How You Want Them Told
- Which performance metrics do you want included in the contract and ongoing reporting?
- How frequently do you want performance and production reports?
- Do you require independent verification or third-party testing for acceptance milestones?
- What level of SCADA access and data sharing is acceptable to you for performance validation?
- What acceptance-test thresholds or protocols do you expect (briefly describe technical expectations)?
The Trade-offs — What Would You Be Willing to Bend On?
- Which trade-offs are you willing to consider to improve schedule or reduce price?
- Which commercial levers would you entertain if it improved bankability or lowered financing costs?
- How flexible are you on turbine selection if alternative models materially improve LCOE or delivery timing?
- Share an example where your organization accepted a trade-off — what was the choice and outcome?
- What criteria would you use to evaluate whether a proposed trade-off is acceptable?
Decision Rhythm — Who Signs and When?
- What is your internal decision timeline for selecting a developer/OEM and finalizing major commercial terms?
- Who are the decision-makers and approvers that must sign off (titles/committees)?
- What approval gates (technical / commercial / board / regulatory) would we need to plan for?
- What documentation or assurances do your lenders or board require before greenlighting the project?
- Is there a single date by which the project must be contracted to meet your internal commitments? If so, what is it?
Next Steps That Build Confidence — What Would You Like From Us?
- What would make you feel ready to move from discovery to a mutual commercial proposal?
- Would you be interested in a short technical workshop or joint modelling session to stress-test assumptions?
- Who should be the primary point of contact for next steps (name, role, email/phone)?
- What is the best timeline for a follow-up meeting to review a tailored outcome proposal?
- Is there any additional context, recent modelling, or constraints we should review before building options for you?
-
Solution Experience
Walk through how our turbine platforms, development approach, and service model deliver the customer’s outcomes in their site, interconnection, and commercial context.
Experience Meetings
- Current State & Consequence Validation
- Site & Interconnection Fit — Turbine Platform Mapping
- Commercial Structure & LCOE Sensitivity Workshop
- Service Model & Availability Assurance
- Integrated Scenario Walkthrough & Confirmation
- Secure validation from customer that service terms mitigate their defined consequences.
- Align on the target LCOE/PPA range and the primary financial sensitivities that must be controlled.
- Select the preferred commercial structure (PPA/BT/JV) and document required risk allocations.
- Agree on the financial assumptions to carry into the Solution Scope model runs.
- Share the LCOE sensitivity workbook with the customer and mark the agreed assumptions.
- Prepare a recommendation memo on the preferred commercial structure with pros/cons and required contractual protections.
- Assign finance and legal owners to draft initial commercial term points for the Solution Scope.
- Restate Availability & Energy Certainty Targets
- Demonstrate proof that our service model can meet the customer's availability target.
- Agree on SLA metrics, guarantee levels, and acceptable contingency allocations for inclusion in Solution Scope.
- Introductions & Objectives
- Provide the service-performance evidence package (fleet data, case studies, warranty claims history) to the customer.
- Draft SLA term sheet with agreed KPIs and penalty structure for legal review.
- Schedule a follow-up with customer O&M and finance owners to finalize contingency sizing.
- Recap Agreed Current State, Consequence, Future State
- Get explicit customer validation that the integrated solution achieves the future-state outcome in the likely scenario.
- Document failure modes for the worst-case scenario and agree mitigations, owners, and costs.
- Secure a clear decision or a list of pre-conditions to start the Solution Scope phase.
- Publish the integrated scenario report (best/likely/worst) with confirmed assumptions and customer validation notes.
- Assign owners and deadlines for each mitigation item identified in the worst-case scenario.
- Schedule the Solution Scope kickoff with confirmed attendees and deliverables.
- Agree a single, customer-validated one-sentence current state.
- Quantify the primary consequences (cost, delay, regulatory exposure) of the current state for the customer's business.
- Define a one-sentence future-state outcome with measurable targets (LCOE range, availability %, energy certainty).
- Confirm the decision owners and next gating milestone to move forward.
- Publish the finalized one-sentence current state and consequence memo to the shared channel.
- Deliver a one-page future-state target summary (LCOE, availability, timeline) for use in subsequent sessions.
- List and contact the named decision owners; confirm next gate date.
- Recap Validated Current/Future State
- Produce a customer-validated short-list of 1–3 turbine platforms tied to measurable outcomes.
- Identify any site or interconnection red flags that would prevent reaching the agreed future state.
- Agree the next engineering actions (detailed micrositing, model runs) and owners.
- Deliver the platform comparison memo that maps metrics (AEP, availability, fleet track record) to the customer's targets.
- Schedule detailed micrositing and wake-loss analysis with engineering and provide data requests to customer.
- Log any red-flag mitigations and assign owners with target dates.
- One‑Sentence Financial Future State
- Scenario Walkthrough — Best Case (Diagnosis -> Proof -> Validation)
- Fleet Performance Proof
- Baseline LCOE Build-up
- One‑Sentence Current State Confirmation
- Site Wind Resource & Queue Constraints Summary
- Consequence Quantification
- Predictive Maintenance & SCADA Analytics (How it prevents the consequence)
- Scenario Walkthrough — Likely Case (Diagnosis -> Proof -> Validation)
- Sensitivity Scenarios (Diagnosis -> Proof)
- Turbine Platform Fit: Trade-offs and Proof
- Scenario Walkthrough — Worst Case & Mitigations
- Define Future-State Outcomes
- Commercial Structures & Risk Allocation
- Micrositing & Grid Interface Implications
- SLA, Guarantees & Contingency Allocation
- Forced Validation Exercise
- Confirm Decision Roles & Near-Term Gates
- Validation: Do These SLAs Resolve Your Consequence?
- Customer Validation & Preferred Path
- Decision & Next Steps to Solution Scope
-
Solution Scope
Define capacity, turbine model selection, micrositing, balance-of-plant scope, commercial structure (PPA/BT/JV), milestones, and responsibility split.
Scope Configuration
- Supply and Deliver Turbine Components (nacelle, tower, blades)
- Transport and Erect Turbine Assemblies
- Construct Turbine Foundations and Anchor Systems
- Build Access Roads and Crane Pads
- Install Array and Export Cables
- Install Onsite Substation and Switchgear
- Install Offshore Foundations and Transition Pieces
- Install and Bury Subsea Export Cables
- Install SCADA Telemetry and Remote Control
- Commission Turbines and Run Performance Tests
- Provide Full-Service Operations and Maintenance
- Execute Predictive Maintenance via SCADA Analytics
- Perform Blade Inspection, Repair, and Replacement
- Overhaul and Exchange Gearbox and Generator
- Supply Spare Parts Inventory and Logistics Hub
Scope Questions
Supply and Deliver Turbine Components (nacelle, tower, blades)
- Do you require the OEM to supply full turbine assemblies (nacelle, hub, blades, tower) or partial scope?
- What turbine rated power(s) and platform(s) are you targeting for this project? (list MW per platform)
- How many turbine units are in scope (units) and what is the total installed capacity (MW)?
- Are there site-specific design requirements for towers or blades (e.g., cold climate, extended warranty, noise-reduced configuration)? Please specify.
- Do you require factory acceptance testing, third-party inspection, or certification accompanying deliveries?
Transport and Erect Turbine Assemblies
- Will the supplier manage heavy-lift transportation and on-site erection or is contractor-provided?
- What are the maximum on-route constraints (e.g., bridge load limits, height/width restrictions) or permit variances known?
- What crane sizes and crane-lift strategy are expected (e.g., single heavy lift, tandem lift, in-field blade assembly)?
- Are there staging yards, marshalling areas, or port calls that require coordination with transport?
- Are seasonal or weather windows constraining transport/erection (e.g., winter shutdown, bird migration)?
Construct Turbine Foundations and Anchor Systems
- Which foundation types are anticipated for turbines on this project?
- Are geotechnical investigations complete for each turbine location (boreholes, CPT, lab testing)?
- Are there known subsurface constraints (shallow rock, high water table, peat, contamination) that impact foundation design?
- Do you require the supplier to deliver foundation design + build, or design-only deliverables for EPC to construct?
- Are environmental or permitting constraints (vibration limits, cultural resources, marine mammal windows) affecting foundation works?
Build Access Roads and Crane Pads
- What access requirements exist per turbine (new roads, upgrades, temporary crane pads)?
- What is the expected distance from nearest paved public road to turbine locations (km)?
- Are there environmental or landowner restrictions on road footprint, drainage, or seasonal access?
- Do you require road and pad design to accommodate specific crane classes or abnormal loads?
- Should road construction include long-term maintenance handback or be built for temporary construction only?
Install Array and Export Cables
- What cable system scope is required (array only, array + underground export, buried export to POI)?
- What typical array lengths and export distance to POI are expected (m per turbine / km to substation)?
- Do you require the supplier to provide cable design, procurement, and installation or only supply/engineering?
- Are there known ground conditions or obstacles (rock, wetlands, sensitive habitats) that affect burial method or cable routing?
- Which cable type and rating is anticipated for array/export (e.g., 33 kV, 66 kV, 132 kV)?
Install Onsite Substation and Switchgear
- What electrical scope is required at the POI (collector substation, switchyard, MV/LV arrangement)?
- What nominal voltage and protection requirements are expected at site (kV and grid code notes)?
- Does the substation scope include transformers, reactive compensation, and SCADA integration?
- Are civil and fencing/site security works required as part of substation delivery?
- Will the substation be built to hand over to a TSO/utility or retained by owner/operator?
Install Offshore Foundations and Transition Pieces
- Is the project offshore, and if so, what water depth range applies to foundation locations (m)?
- Which foundation/transition-piece types are anticipated (monopile, jacket, floating spar/semisub, gravity base)?
- Do you require fabrication, transport, and installation inclusive in scope or separate contractors?
- Are offshore metocean, seabed survey, and marine mammal/eco windows completed to permit installation?
- Will specialized vessels or heavy-lift barges be required and should supplier secure them?
Install and Bury Subsea Export Cables
- Is there an offshore export cable run to shore and what is the approximate length (km)?
- Do you require HV submarine cable system design, manufacture, burial and rock placement or ploughing?
- Are there marine route constraints (shipping lanes, protected areas, cable crossings) to consider for installation planning?
- Is post-lay survey, cable protection, and as-built documentation required as part of scope?
- Will onshore transition pits and beach landing works be part of the supplier scope?
Install SCADA Telemetry and Remote Control
- Do you require full SCADA package delivery including RTUs, telemetry, and HMI, or integration with existing systems?
- Which communications media are preferred/available for telemetry (fiber, microwave, cellular, satellite)?
- What control and availability requirements must SCADA support (remote start/stop, curtailment, reactive control)?
- Are cybersecurity standards or ISO/NERC requirements applicable to SCADA and telemetry?
- Do you require 24/7 monitoring services, alarm handling and incident response as part of the SCADA scope?
Commission Turbines and Run Performance Tests
- What acceptance tests and KPIs are required prior to mechanical/electrical handover (capacity tests, availability, power curve verification)?
- Who will witness commissioning tests (owner, lender, third-party verifier) and are witness windows predetermined?
- Are site-specific commissioning constraints present (grid availability windows, restricted energization periods)?
- Do you require a structured performance acceptance period with guarantees (e.g., PPA acceptance, ramp tests over X months)?
- Should the commissioning scope include documentation handover (O&M manuals, as-built drawings, SCADA logs)?
Provide Full-Service Operations and Maintenance
- What O&M contract duration and coverage are you seeking?
- Do you require full-service (all corrective & preventive) or partial (service-by-exception) O&M?
- Are guaranteed availability/performance SLAs expected and what target availability is required (e.g., 97%)?
- Do you require on-site spares, dedicated service crews, and local warehousing as part of the O&M package?
- Should O&M include remote monitoring, scheduled preventative maintenance visits, and emergency response SLA tiers?
Execute Predictive Maintenance via SCADA Analytics
- Do you want predictive maintenance enabled using SCADA analytics and machine-learning models?
- What data streams will be available for analytics (SCADA channels, vibration sensors, oil sensors, blade accelerometers)?
- Do you require a cloud analytics platform with dashboard access, or periodic analytics reports and recommended work orders?
- Should predictive analytics integrate with work-order systems and trigger automatic scheduling of maintenance crew?
- Are there data security, ownership, or sharing constraints for analytics outputs (e.g., third-party models, IP rights)?
-
Mutual Commit
Finalize commercial and legal terms, performance and availability guarantees, contingency allocations, and sign-off timeline.
Agreement Modules
- Primary Commercial Agreement (PPA/BT/JV)
- Master Services Agreement (MSA)
- Statement of Work (SOW)
- Turbine Supply Agreement (TSA)
- EPC / Balance-of-Plant Contract
- Operations & Maintenance (O&M) Agreement
- Performance & Availability Guarantees
- Financial Security & Payment Mechanisms
- Insurance & Risk Allocation Schedule
- Interconnection & Grid Agreement
- Land Rights, Permits & Easement Assignments
- Contingency, Change Order & Cost Allocation
- Acceptance Certificate & Commissioning Protocol
- Warranties, Spare Parts & Lifecycle Support
- Closing Conditions & Sign-off Timeline
-
Deployment
Operationalize rollout with readiness checks, enablement, and outcome validation.
-
Pre-Deployment Readiness
Confirm permits, grid agreements, financing draw conditions, supply-chain slots, and named owners are in place for execution.
Readiness Questions
Start Here: The Big Picture You're Trying to Solve
- What is the primary objective driving your interest in wind generation right now?
- What timeline are you targeting for final investment decision (FID) and first energy?
- Who on your team will be directly responsible for procurement, finance, and board approvals? (name, role, and ideal point of contact)
- Which commercial structure(s) are you actively considering?
- How urgent does this decision feel to your executive team on a scale from 'exploratory' to 'mission-critical'?
Who's Holding the Keys? (Decision Roles, Politics & Hidden Gates)
- Who inside your organization is most likely to block or slow this project—and what usually motivates their hesitation?
- List the formal approval gates and decision thresholds we should expect (procurement committee, finance committee, board thresholds, delegated authorities).
- How do your board or executive stakeholders view long-term PPAs and merchant exposure today—enthusiastic, cautious, or opposed?
- When a project has hit political friction in the past, what remedies or evidence have convinced decision-makers to move forward? Tell us a concrete example.
- If we needed an internal champion to accelerate approvals, what role and qualities would be most persuasive for your organization?
Where the Risk Lives (Permits, Queue Position, Community Heat)
- Which single permitting, interconnection, or community issue do you believe is most likely to derail schedule—and why?
- What is the current status of these specific items for the site: land/lease, environmental permits, local zoning, and community agreements?
- Where do you sit in the interconnection queue today and what contingency do you expect if the queue moves slower than planned?
- Have you experienced community opposition or local permitting delays on past projects? If yes, what tactics helped reduce friction and how long did those delays last?
- Are there any regulatory or market constraints (e.g., state interconnection rules, permitting moratoria, local content requirements) that we should map right away?
Are We Confident in the Resource? (Wind Data, Forecasts & Uncertainty)
- How confident are you that the wind resource assessment reflects realistic year‑one and long‑term production—could those numbers be off by 5%, 10%, or more?
- What type of wind data do you have available today (met mast, LiDAR, SCADA from existing turbines, third‑party assessment)?
- Has an independent third-party verified your AEP model and assumptions? If yes, what were the key findings or caveats?
- If production falls short by a material amount, what financial or contractual levers does your organization prefer (reserves, performance guarantees, indexation, price adjustments)?
- How would a multi-year variability trend (e.g., 10% lower AEP over 3–5 years) make you feel about moving forward—would you pause, renegotiate, or continue?
What’s Your Risk Budget—Really? (Availability, LCOE & Non‑Negotiables)
- If you had to prioritize one non-negotiable outcome—lowest LCOE, highest availability, or guaranteed delivery date—what would it be and why?
- What specific LCOE range and availability target would you need to see to recommend this project to your board?
- How much of the commercial risk are you willing to accept (e.g., availability performance deductions vs. developer/OEM guarantees)?
- Which contractual protections matter most to your lenders or treasury team (e.g., step-in rights, escrow, debt draw triggers, SPV covenants)?
- When you look at past projects, where have contingency budgets been most drained—construction cost overruns, interconnection upgrades, or operational shortfalls? How long has that been a pattern?
Can the Supply Chain & Financing Move at Your Pace?
- If a critical vendor missed delivery by six months, which part of your plan would break first—financing, grid readiness, or commercial commitments?
- Which turbine power class and rotor size range are you most inclined toward for this site?
- Do you currently have supply‑chain reservations or option slots with any OEMs? If so, which and for what delivery window?
- What is the status of project financing (term sheets, committed lenders, internal approval) and what remaining conditions are hardest to satisfy?
- If we offered a staged delivery or partial-supply approach, how open would you be to trade-offs between schedule certainty and price?
If We Built It, Would You Accept It? (Acceptance, Testing & KPIs)
- What single acceptance condition would make you reject commissioning even if other milestones were met (e.g., guaranteed availability, independent performance test, environmental compliance)?
- Which acceptance tests and benchmarks are must-haves for you (power curve validation, full-load testing, SCADA baseline, grid-code compliance)?
- How long of a performance observation window post-commissioning do you require before releasing final acceptance and final payments?
- What KPIs and reporting cadence will satisfy your asset management team for handover into operations (availability %, downtime events, AEP variance, maintenance backlog)?
- If early operational issues arise, what escalation and remediation path gives you confidence (OEM service response times, penalties, third-party oversight)?
A Practical Next Step — Who Does What, By When?
- What is the single piece of information or decision that, if provided this week, would move you from evaluation to a firm next step?
- Which milestones do you need owners for right now (permitting, grid agreement, financing draw, turbine procurement, construction schedule)? Please identify names/roles where possible.
- How quickly would you be willing to sign a non-binding term sheet or MoU if it aligned to your top priorities?
- What openness do you have to joint technical due diligence (shared site visits, data room access, third-party resource verification) and who would lead that from your side?
- Finally, how would you like us to communicate—one weekly touchpoint, detailed bi-weekly reports, or an on-demand shared workspace—and who should be included?
-
Deployment Enablement
Schedule construction, turbine deliveries, commissioning, and O&M mobilization with clear owners, milestones, and escalation paths.
-
Validation Checklist
Verify performance testing, interconnection energization, availability benchmarks, and acceptance criteria are documented and met.
Validation Questions
Start Here — Describe Your Project in One Line
- In one sentence, describe the project or portfolio you’re evaluating for wind energy (location, scale, and stage).
- What best describes the project’s current stage?
- What is the target installed capacity for the opportunity?
- Which commercial structure are you currently considering for this project?
- Who will sign off on the final commercial terms from your side? (select all that apply)
What Keeps Your Board Up at Night?
- If you had to name the single risk that would make your board refuse to proceed, what would it be?
- Which three priorities matter most when the board evaluates a wind project?
- What maximum LCOE or PPA price range would you consider acceptable for this project (baseline expectation)?
- How do you prioritize trade-offs across availability, energy certainty, and price right now?
- Are there regulatory, offtake, or board conditions that would be absolute deal-breakers?
When Did You Last Feel Truly Confident About a Generation Forecast?
- How confident are you that your current resource assessment reflects the actual energy you’ll receive on site?
- What measurement data underpins your current forecast (select all sources you rely on)?
- How many years of on-site, validated wind data do you have?
- Have you completed or requested an independent P50/P90 or uncertainty analysis for financiers?
- What percentage deviation between your P50 and P90 would your financiers accept (approximate)?
- How does potential curtailment or transmission constraint factor into your production forecast and risk tolerance?
Where Execution Tends to Break Down
- Think of previous projects — what execution issue most often derailed timelines or budgets?
- Which execution risks do you view as highest for this project right now? (select all that apply)
- Have you experienced turbine supply or logistics delays in the last 24 months on your projects?
- What contractual protections or remedies do you expect from suppliers if schedule or performance slips occur?
- If a major schedule slip happens, who from your organization will own escalation and mitigation decisions?
- How comfortable are you with the contingency and buffer currently budgeted for schedule and cost overruns?
If Everything Went Right, What Would Success Feel Like?
- Imagine we sign today — three years after COD, what would make you stand up and say, 'we nailed it'?
- Which KPIs will you use to judge whether the project is a success? (select all that apply)
- What minimum average availability % would you require in years 1–5 to consider the project successful?
- What acceptance tests, performance guarantees, or commissioning criteria must be documented and met at handover?
- How important is a predictive-maintenance / data-driven O&M program to achieving your long-term KPIs?
- Would you consider a shared-risk commercial model (e.g., availability-linked pricing) to align incentives?
Non-Negotiables — The Lines You Won’t Cross
- Which single contractual term or operational constraint would make you walk away from a deal immediately?
- Are there environmental, community, or permitting constraints that are absolute for this site? (select all that apply)
- Do your financiers or internal policies require named vendors, minimum insurer ratings, or specific warranty terms?
- What minimum warranty or guaranteed availability term would you require from the OEM (years / % availability)?
- Which payment or financing structures are unacceptable to you?
- How immovable is your timeline — are there regulatory, commercial, or offtake milestones you cannot miss?
What Would a Realistic Next Step Look Like?
- If we could remove your single biggest barrier in 30 days, what is the one deliverable you would ask us for?
- Which immediate next steps would add highest value for you right now? (select all that apply)
- What documents or datasets can you share immediately to accelerate our assessment? (select all that apply)
- Who are the essential decision-makers we should include in a scoping workshop?
- What is your target decision window for moving from discovery to a formal commercial proposal or FPA (firm agreement)?
- How would you prefer we communicate progress and escalate blockers so your team stays comfortable? (select all that apply)
-
-
Success
Confirm long-term performance against KPIs, capture learnings, and maintain a shared channel for issue tracking and continuous improvement.
Success Reviews
- Quarterly Performance Review
- Annual Lessons Learned Workshop
- Issue Triage & Rapid Response
- KPI Governance & Contractual Review
- Continuous Improvement Roadmap & Shared Channel Onboarding
Issues & Enhancements
- Draft and circulate a formal M&V protocol document for sign-off within 15 business days.
- Ensure major incidents have clear root causes, quantified consequences, and corrective measures.
- Agree a publication plan so lessons are accessible to both customer and seller teams.
- Create a Lessons Learned report with RCA appendices and publish to shared channel within 10 business days.
- Launch pilot projects for the top 2 prioritized improvements with named leads and 90-day milestones.
- Update relevant playbooks (O&M, commissioning, emergency response) based on agreed lessons.
- Incident Briefing
- Contain the incident and prevent near-term escalation or further asset damage.
- Assign clear owners, resources, and timelines for recovery actions.
- Ensure transparent communications to all affected stakeholders and regulators as required.
- Technical lead to post a step-by-step containment checklist and immediate evidence (SCADA logs, photos) to the shared channel within 2 hours.
- Operations to mobilize required spare parts and schedule a repair window; confirm by end of day.
- Customer relations to draft external notification for counterparties/regulators if impact exceeds contractual thresholds.
- Confirm KPI Definitions
- Establish unambiguous KPI definitions and M&V procedures agreed by both parties.
- Agree on a fair, auditable reconciliation process for performance-related financial settlements.
- Set a governance calendar and formal roles to reduce future disputes.
- Welcome & Objectives
- Legal and commercial teams to prepare proposed contract language for any agreed KPI changes.
- Schedule quarterly governance checkpoints and publish calendar invites to governance members.
- Current State of Tools & Integrations
- Onboard the shared issue-tracking channel with agreed workflows and SLAs.
- Define measurable improvement milestones tied to KPIs and select initial pilots.
- Ensure all relevant teams have access and basic training scheduled to use the channel effectively.
- Platform admin to create the shared channel with ticket templates and populate initial issues within 5 business days.
- IT/Integration team to scope and begin connecting SCADA and CMMS data feeds to the dashboard within 20 business days.
- Schedule two 60-minute training sessions for users and owners within the first month of channel activation.
- Establish whether contractual and operational KPIs were met and quantify any shortfalls.
- Assign owners and timelines for remediation of out-of-tolerance issues.
- Ensure the shared issue tracker reflects agreed actions and SLAs.
- Owner(s) to publish detailed performance packet (raw data + M&V notes) to shared channel within 3 business days.
- Assigned technical leads to open tracker tickets for each remediation action with milestone dates.
- Operations team to schedule a focused follow-up in 30 days for unresolved high-impact items.
- Context & Desired Outcomes
- Produce a prioritized list of improvement initiatives with owners and timelines.
- KPI Dashboard Review
- Impact Assessment
- Successes & Wins Review
- Define Ticket Types & Workflow
- M&V Methodology & Data Sources
- Incident & Failure Reviews
- Immediate Containment Actions
- Reconciliation & Financial Settlement
- SLA & Escalation Matrix
- Deviation & Impact Analysis
- Dashboard & KPI Enhancements
- Root Cause Summary
- Change Management & Contract Amendments
- Consequence Quantification
- Recovery Plan & Timeline
- Training & Onboarding Plan
- Communications & Escalation
- Governance Calendar & Roles
- Brainstorming: Process & Technical Improvements
- Corrective Actions & Owners
- Update Shared Issue Tracker
- Tracker Update & Follow-up
- Prioritization & Pilot Selection
- Roadmap & Pilot Commitments
- Documenting & Publishing Lessons