Storage & Transportation
Capital-intensive extraction and processing programs where safety, regulation, and supply chain complexity define execution.
Inside this journey
-
Pre-Discovery
Align the room on outcomes, decision process, and constraints before deeper discovery.
-
Stakeholder Alignment
Confirm decision roles, timelines, constraints, and approval criteria across marketing, supply, and commercial stakeholders.
Alignment Questions
Start Here: Who’s in the Room and What’s Their Job?
- Who is the primary contact driving this storage/transport need?
- Which internal teams must sign off before a commercial commitment is executed?
- What is your typical internal approval timeline from initial ask to signature?
- Who has day-to-day nomination authority for the volumes involved?
- Are there non-negotiable approval criteria (e.g., minimum capacity guarantee, contamination indemnity, rate caps)? If so, list them.
Is Capacity Actually Holding You Back—or Are We Treating Symptoms?
- If you could remove the single biggest constraint on moving barrels today, what would it be and why?
- Which capacity issues are you most often wrestling with?
- Approximately how many barrels per month do you need to place above your current takeaway capacity (choose the closest)?
- Which products are driving the need for storage or alternate transport?
- How long do you expect this elevated need to persist?
- How long has this capacity shortfall been affecting your operations?
When Deliveries Fail: Where Does the Pain Land?
- Think of the worst delivery failure you've experienced—what happened and what was the real business impact?
- Which failure modes occur most often for you?
- How frequently do quality or contamination issues lead to rejected receipts or rejections downstream?
- What are the typical commercial or operational consequences when a delivery fails (select all that apply)?
- How quickly can your team detect and escalate a delivery or quality failure today?
- Who on your team leads incident response and who has final say on remediation decisions?
What Would Breathing Room Actually Let You Do?
- If storage/transport became a strategic lever rather than a stopgap, what new actions would you take?
- Which outcomes matter most to you from a solution?
- Which success metrics should we use to judge the service?
- What delivery windows and heel flexibility would be acceptable for your operations?
- What minimum days-of-cover (inventory buffer) would make you comfortable?
- Are there specific quality or regulatory specs we must guarantee?
What Trade-offs Are You Willing to Make?
- Would you prioritize price, capacity certainty, or operational flexibility if you could only have two?
- Would interruptible capacity at lower cost be acceptable for some portion of needs?
- Are you open to longer contract terms in exchange for rate discounts or priority nominations?
- Is product commingling in shared tanks acceptable, or do you require dedicated segregation?
- Who on your team is authorized to negotiate trade-offs (commercial vs operational)?
Operational Reality: How Will This Work Day-to-Day?
- How confident are you that nominations, physical flows, and SCADA will align on day one of a new connection?
- What SCADA/data integration do you require (select all required data points)?
- What nomination windows and cutoffs does your operation currently run on?
- Do you require EDI/API integration for nominations and confirmations or is manual submission acceptable?
- What internal resources will you dedicate to onboarding and ongoing ops (people, hours per week)?
- Who is the day-to-day ops owner and who is the escalation contact on your side?
Money, Risk, and Decision Triggers
- What single commercial term would make you greenlight a deal today?
- What target rate ranges do you have in mind (per bbl per month / per bbl lift)?
- Which commercial protections are essential to you?
- What payment terms and credit structures are acceptable?
- What internal decision milestones determine go/no-go (e.g., budget approval, board signoff, counterparty credit)?
Would a Pilot Win You Over—or Raise New Questions?
- If we proposed a pilot, what minimum duration would demonstrate value to you?
- Which KPIs must a pilot hit to be considered successful?
- What operational or commercial risks during a pilot would be deal-breakers?
- What internal resources could you commit to run a pilot (schedulers, ops, trading desk)?
- Would you prefer a scoped pilot on interruptible capacity first, or a small firm commitment pilot?
How This Feels for Your Team: The Human Side
- How much cognitive load does managing constrained logistics add to your team’s week?
- When logistics fail, which emotion best describes your team's reaction?
- How does delivery uncertainty affect commercial choices like hedging, bidding, or contracting?
- If a partner provided predictable delivery and transparent reporting, what would that free your team to focus on?
- What worries would you want addressed first to feel comfortable moving ahead?
-
Current State Mapping
Map production flows, existing takeaway constraints, inventory positions, connectivity, and failure modes affecting delivery.
Current State
Tell Us How It Really Runs Today
- In one sentence, how would you describe your current takeaway and storage situation?
- Which storage and handling types are you actively using today?
- What is your typical monthly throughput (in barrels) into and out of the facility footprint we’d be working with?
- What are the primary reasons you use external storage or transport today (select all that apply)?
- Which market hubs do you most frequently move product toward from these assets?
Why Do Deliveries Miss the Plan?
- When you think about missed nominations or short deliveries, what single assumption do you catch your team making most often?
- How frequently do you experience apportionment, curtailed nominations, or force-majeure impacts that change expected deliveries?
- Tell us about a recent example when deliveries deviated significantly—what happened, and what was the downstream impact?
- Which of these contributes most to unpredictable deliveries on your side?
- How does unpredictability feel for your team—frustrating, financially painful, reputationally risky, or something else?
Where Are The Invisible Bottlenecks Hiding?
- What small restriction in the network today do you suspect is silently capping your deliverable volume?
- Which physical limits create the tightest pinch points for you right now?
- Are there contractual or commercial limits (e.g., minimum dwell, nomination windows, reserved capacity) that effectively reduce usable capacity?
- How often do operational hours (e.g., 24/7 vs business hours) or turn times force you to leave product on the table?
- If you had one telemetry or measurement you didn’t have today that would instantly reveal a bottleneck, what would it be?
Do You Really See Your Flows in Real Time?
- How confident are you in the accuracy and timeliness of your flow and inventory data today?
- What systems currently provide your operational visibility (select all that apply)?
- Do you have automated feeds for nominations, confirmations, and actuals into your planning systems? If not, where does the handoff break down?
- How long does it typically take to reconcile a discrepancy between nominated and actual volumes?
- Who on your team is responsible for resolving data mismatches, and what is the escalation path?
Is Your 'Available' Capacity Practically Usable?
- What percentage of nominal storage capacity do you treat as usable versus reserved (heel, quality buffer, operational buffer)?
- Do you have fixed heel or segregation requirements that reduce advertised capacity? Please describe.
- How often do contamination concerns (mixing grades, water, H2S, etc.) force you to reject or rework loads?
- Which of these best describes the split between committed (firm) and interruptible volumes in your current agreements?
- Have past operational practices or site rules created patterns you now accept but would change if given the choice? If so, what are they?
Who Really Makes the Call When The Window Is Tight?
- Who has final authority to change nominations, re-route volumes, or release inventory on your side during an operational incident?
- When an urgent decision is needed, what is the typical decision timeline and who must be looped in?
- How aligned are commercial and operational teams on acceptable delivery windows and penalties?
- Do you have pre-agreed escalation paths or war-room procedures with your storage/transport providers? If yes, how often are they used?
- Which internal stakeholder will most feel the pain if delivery risk materializes (select one)?
Tell Us About Your Worst Breakdowns—We Learn Faster That Way
- Describe the worst delivery or storage failure you've experienced in the last 24 months and what caused it.
- How long did it take to fully recover normal operations after that event?
- What contingency playbook did you use, and what part of it failed or succeeded?
- What were the top direct costs from that failure (select all that apply)?
- Since that event, what changes did you put in place—and what unresolved gaps remain?
Is Your Network As Flexible As Your Org Thinks?
- How many distinct pipeline, rail, or truck routes do you realistically have access to from your production/storage footprint?
- Are there routing constraints (batching, commingling rules, pump limitations) that make some connections unusable at scale?
- Which downstream market moves are you unable to execute today due to connectivity or batching limits?
- If we could provide a new physical connection or guaranteed pump/slot, which market or operation would you prioritize?
- How quickly could you re-route volumes if an alternate connection were available (hours, days, weeks)?
What Quality Risks Are Lurking In Plain Sight?
- Have you experienced contamination or off‑spec deliveries in the last 12 months? Tell us what happened.
- How are acceptance criteria and testing windows managed between your team and terminals or pipelines?
- What laboratory or on-site test turnaround time do you typically face before a load is accepted or rejected?
- If contamination occurred, who pays for remediation and how quickly can the tank or batch be returned to service?
- How much operational uncertainty does the possibility of contamination introduce into your trading or supply plans?
What Small Changes Would Immediately Stop the Bleeding?
- If you could change one operational rule or contract term today to reduce missed deliveries, what would it be?
- Which of the following near-term fixes would deliver the most value to your team?
- How open is your organization to pilot-test a new operational approach (data sharing, slot reservations, or blended pricing) on a short-term basis?
- What would success look like after a 90-day improvement run—specific metrics, not aspirations?
- Who on your side would need to sign off to run a short pilot and who would operate it day-to-day?
-
-
Outcome Discovery
Define target outcomes, acceptable delivery windows, heel flexibility needs, and success metrics for storage and transport.
Discovery Questions
Getting Oriented: What Brought You Here?
- What prompted you to explore additional storage or transport options right now?
- Tell us about the typical volumes you need to place into storage (daily and peak monthly).
- Which product types are we discussing for this opportunity?
- Who on your team will be directly responsible for nominations, quality acceptance, and commercial sign‑off?
- If you had to pick one short-term business goal from this engagement, what is it?
What’s the Cost of Doing Nothing?
- If nothing changes in the next 90 days, what is the single biggest downside you expect to face?
- How often have takeaway constraints or scheduling limits caused you to miss a delivery or take a lower price in the past 12 months?
- Can you quantify the financial impact when those events occur (range or example trade)?
- What emotional or reputational effects do these disruptions create internally—frustration, overtime, strained customer relationships?
- How long has this pattern been happening, and what have you tried so far to mitigate it?
When Would Perfect Delivery Feel Like a Win?
- If storage and transport worked perfectly for you, what outcome would make you say “that was worth it”?
- What specific KPIs would prove success to your finance, operations, and commercial teams (list top 3)?
- What time horizon matters for those outcomes—next week, quarter, season, or multi‑year?
- Which of these would be a deal maker for you: guaranteed throughput windows, committed storage days, or lowest all‑in cost? Rank or describe.
- Give an example of a recent transaction you wish had a different storage/transport outcome—what would a better outcome have enabled?
The Heel and the Edge: How Much Flexibility Do You Need?
- How comfortable are you with leaving heel in tanks or caverns versus requiring near‑empty turnarounds?
- What heel percentage or absolute volume would be acceptable for your product to stay operationally and commercially viable?
- How sensitive is your downstream process to residual product or blend variability coming out of storage?
- Have you experienced contamination or off‑spec events before? If yes, what happened and how was it resolved?
- If we proposed heel‑management options (dedicated segregation, blending, cleaning windows), which would you prefer and why?
Timing and Windows That Make or Break Your Business
- How often do your nominations change within the 24–72 hour window before movement?
- What nomination cadence and cut‑off times are essential for you to meet commercial commitments?
- How much last‑mile loading capacity (truck/rail) do you need during peak windows and what creates pinch points?
- If faced with a constrained nomination window, what tradeoffs are you willing to make—price, quantity, or timing?
- Describe a worst‑case scheduling failure you've had—what was the knock‑on effect to operations and customers?
How Do You Measure Success (and Who Signs Off)?
- Who are the decision‑makers that must be satisfied for a successful arrangement (names/titles and their main criteria)?
- Which commercial metrics matter most for approval: $/bbl/month, committed throughput fees, service credits, or exposure to rate escalations?
- What operational acceptance criteria must be met before handover (first nomination success, SCADA validation, product sample results)?
- How frequently do you want performance reporting (daily, weekly, on‑demand) and what format helps you act fastest?
- What contractual terms would you require for go/no‑go decision: trial/pilot length, exit windows, or performance SLAs?
Contingencies, Failure Modes, and Trust: What Keeps You Awake?
- When the unexpected happens—apportionment, pipeline outage, extreme weather—what outcome would let you sleep at night?
- Which past incident eroded your confidence in providers the most, and what did you wish they had done differently?
- What level of insurance, indemnity, or financial protection do you require for storage/transport arrangements?
- How quickly do you expect operational issues to be acknowledged and resolved (SLA for response and resolution)?
- Who on your side must be looped into escalations and what details do they need to act decisively?
If We Could Move Forward Today, What Would Make You Say Yes?
- What are the non‑negotiables that must appear in any commercial proposal for you to consider signing?
- Would you prefer a short pilot with reduced terms to validate operations, or a full commercial term up front?
- What timeline and internal approvals would we be working toward if you were ready to proceed?
- What information or guarantees would reduce your perceived risk enough to commit (e.g., reference operations, financial terms, technical integration plan)?
- Finally, who should we schedule for a technical deep‑dive to align on SCADA, sampling, and nomination integration?
-
Solution Experience
Use customer scenarios (seasonal inventory, contango plays, overflow volumes) to confirm how storage and transport achieve the desired outcomes and mitigate risks.
Experience Meetings
- Current State & Consequence Calibration
- Scenario Workshop — Seasonal Inventory & Overflow Volumes
- Scenario Workshop — Contango Plays & Trading Optionality
- Operational Runbook, Contamination Controls & Escalation
- Commercial Impact Review & Proceed/Terminate Decision
- Agree SCADA/data checks and nomination verification steps required before first movements.
- Joint to identify one pilot seasonal window for an operational test or tabletop drill.
- Recap Target Outcome for Trading Use Case
- Provide concrete P&L thresholds that guide when contango plays are profitable after all costs.
- Agree operational execution steps and the minimum connectivity/nominations required to realize trades.
- Define guardrails and who may authorize trades when market conditions change.
- Provider to run sensitivity matrix (storage rate, transport apportionment, delay days) and share results.
- Traders to provide target spread thresholds and internal approval limits for automated guardrails.
- Joint to define monitoring KPIs and alerting thresholds to be implemented in SCADA/ops dashboards.
- Review Accepted Scenarios and Decisions
- Produce a draft operational runbook with named owners and timelines for each critical action.
- Introductions & Meeting Objective
- Establish contamination control processes and explicit go/no-go acceptance criteria.
- Provider to produce the operational runbook draft (including flow diagrams, owners, and checklists) within 5 business days.
- Customer ops to schedule a SCADA test window and provide access credentials for data feed verification.
- Joint to schedule a tabletop drill using the runbook to validate roles and timing before any live movements.
- Recap Scenario Outcomes & Operational Readiness
- Enable commercial approvers to see net economic impact of chosen scenario and select a contracting path.
- Secure a clear decision to proceed to Solution Scope or capture precise negotiation deliverables and timelines.
- Document any commercial contingencies required before final mutual commit.
- Provider to issue a commercial term sheet and cost breakout for the selected scenario within 2 business days.
- Customer commercial VP to indicate preferred contracting option (committed vs interruptible) and any required protections.
- If unresolved, assign negotiation owners and schedule the commercial follow-up meeting with deadlines.
- Produce an agreed single-sentence current state that all parties can recite.
- Agree numeric consequence baseline (financial and operational) to measure scenario benefit.
- Confirm dataset owners and delivery timelines for scenario modeling.
- List top 3 constraints/failure modes that scenarios must address.
- Customer to deliver nomination history, production forecast, and quality specs (12 months) to provider.
- Provider to deliver terminal/pipeline connectivity map, available tank types, heel rules, and current capacity snapshot.
- Joint to agree on success metrics (e.g., $ saved, barrels preserved, reduction in contingency events) for scenario comparison.
- Recap Current State & Success Metrics
- Demonstrate a modeled seasonal plan that reduces the quantified consequence relative to baseline.
- Validate nomination windows, loading cadence, and estimated timings required to avoid production curtailment.
- Agree on residual risks and specific operational mitigations to include in the runbook.
- Provider to deliver the scenario model workbook (flows, timelines, cost delta) within 3 business days.
- Customer to confirm acceptable heel volumes and any regulatory or contract limits that affect seasonal storage.
- One‑Sentence Current State
- Runbook Walk‑Through: Steps & Owners
- Assumptions & Price Curve Inputs
- Scenario Assumptions & Inputs
- Commercial Options & Cost Impact
- Tradeoffs & Contractual Guardrails
- SCADA/Data & Nomination Integration
- Model Walk‑Through: Flow & Delivery Proof
- P&L Break‑Even & Sensitivity Walkthrough
- Consequence Quantification
- Decision & Next Steps
- Execution Mechanics & Operational Proof
- Risk Mitigation Mapping
- Quality Controls & Contamination Procedures
- Constraints & Failure Modes
- Escalation Path & Go/No‑Go Acceptance Criteria
- Validation & Forced Confirmation
- Data & Assumptions for Modeling
- Guardrails & Approval Triggers
- Validation by Trader/Commercial Rep
- Final Validation Exercise
- Validation Checkpoint
-
Solution Scope
Specify storage types, committed vs interruptible quantities, connectivity, loading modes, SCADA/data integration, nomination windows, and responsibilities.
Scope Configuration
- Committed Above-Ground Tank Storage (monthly barrels)
- Interruptible Spot Tank Storage
- Salt-Cavern NGL Storage Injection/Withdrawal
- Firm Pipeline Transportation to Market Hubs
- Pipeline Receipt and Delivery Services
- Truck Loading and Unloading Terminal Operations
- Railcar Loading, Unloading, and Storage
- Custody Transfer Metering and Volume Allocation
- In-line Sampling and Laboratory Quality Testing
- Product Blending and Grade Adjustment
- Tank Heel Management and Dedicated Segregation
- SCADA Metering Integration and Live Volume Reporting
Scope Questions
Committed Above-Ground Tank Storage (monthly barrels)
- What committed monthly volume (barrels per month) do you need reserved?
- What contract term are you seeking for committed storage?
- Which product types will occupy committed tanks?
- Do you require dedicated tanks or pooled (fungible) inventory?
- What minimum usable tank capacity per tank do you require (if dedicated)?
- Are there delivery timing constraints for committed storage (e.g., fixed monthly windows)? Please describe.
- Do you require guaranteed nomination windows or priority over interruptible volumes?
Interruptible Spot Tank Storage
- How often do you anticipate using interruptible/spot storage?
- What maximum single-transaction spot volume might you request?
- What lead time can you accept for provider notification of interruption or recall of spot volumes?
- Are you willing to accept partial fills or apportionment on spot requests?
- What pricing model do you prefer for spot storage?
- Do you require nomination/time-window guarantees for spot loads/unloads?
- Any product quality, contamination sensitivity, or segregation needs for spot inventory?
Salt-Cavern NGL Storage Injection/Withdrawal
- Which NGL products or blends will be stored in caverns?
- What injection and withdrawal rate requirements do you need (bpd or bph)?
- What cyclicity do you anticipate (continuous storage, seasonal peak injection/withdrawal, trading cycles)?
- Do you require minimum inventory or working gas targets held in cavern at all times?
- Are there pressure/thermodynamic constraints, heating or compression needs, or special equipment for injection/withdrawal?
- Do you require SCADA telemetry and remote control for cavern operations?
- What contamination controls, additive requirements, or blending limitations apply to cavern-stored product?
Firm Pipeline Transportation to Market Hubs
- Which origin and destination hubs are included in the requested firm pipeline service?
- What firm throughput do you require (bpd or bph) and for what term?
- What nomination cadence and windows do you require (daily, intra-day, weekly)?
- Are quality specs (gravity, BS&W, sulfur) required for pipeline receipts/deliveries?
- Do you require scheduling priority, imbalance tolerance, or flexibility in reassigning nominations?
- Are backhaul moves, batching, or transloading to rail/truck part of the scope?
- What penalty or make-good arrangements for under/over nomination do you require?
Pipeline Receipt and Delivery Services
- Which specific receipt and delivery points will you use (list PTIDs/locations)?
- Do you require custody-transfer metering at the receipt, delivery, or both locations?
- What minimum notice and scheduling lead times are acceptable for receipts and deliveries?
- Are batching, segregation, or commingling rules required at the delivery point?
- Do you need physical tie-in works or pigging/cleaning before first receipt/delivery?
- What SLA or acceptance criteria should be applied to receipts/deliveries (e.g., acceptance within X hours)?
Truck Loading and Unloading Terminal Operations
- How many truck positions/racks will you require and what max loading rate per rack?
- What hours of operation are required (business hours, 24/7, shift coverage)?
- Do you require an appointment/slotting system for trucks?
- What truck types and ADR/hazard classifications will you use?
- Do you require weighbridge, bill of lading integration, and automatic manifesting?
- What demurrage or detention policies are acceptable for trucks?
- Are product swap, blending or pre-shipment sampling requirements needed at truck racks?
Railcar Loading, Unloading, and Storage
- Do you require unit train capability or single-car spot loading/unloading?
- What railcar types and DOT specifications are expected (tank car models, coatings)?
- What loading/unloading rate (cars per day) and turnaround time do you need?
- Is on-site storage of loaded/unloaded cars required and for how long?
- Do you need transloading between rail and pipeline/truck, or direct pipeline connection?
- Are safety, DOT inspection, and cleaning services required as part of rail scope?
Custody Transfer Metering and Volume Allocation
- Where do you require custody transfer metering (receipt, delivery, both)?
- What metering technology and accuracy class do you require?
- What allocation rules and split factors should apply when commingled volumes exist?
- What calibration, testing frequency, and certification requirements do you require for meters?
- Do you require third-party audit rights or independent meter verifications?
- How should metering disputes be handled (escalation path, holdback, sample testing)?
In-line Sampling and Laboratory Quality Testing
- Which quality tests must be performed (e.g., API gravity, BS&W, sulfur, water, chloride)?
- What sampling frequency is required (per transfer, daily, weekly, per tank movement)?
- Do you require an on-site lab, mobile sampling, or third-party accredited lab analysis?
- What turnaround time for quality results do you require for acceptance decisions?
- Are chain-of-custody and certified reports required for commercial transfers?
- What escalation and rejection criteria should be applied if product fails specs?
Product Blending and Grade Adjustment
- Do you require blending capabilities to meet target specs or create marketable grades?
-
Mutual Commit
Finalize commercial terms, service levels, contamination controls, escalation paths, and acceptance criteria for go/no-go.
Agreement Modules
- Statement of Work (SOW)
- Master Services Agreement (MSA)
- Capacity Commitment Agreement
- Rate Schedule & Billing Terms
- Service Level Agreement (SLA) & Remedies
- Storage Services Agreement
- Transportation Agreement
- Quality & Contamination Control Protocol
- Inspection, Sampling & Acceptance Plan
- SCADA & Data Integration Agreement
- Nomination & Scheduling Protocol
- Operational Acceptance Criteria (Go/No‑Go Checklist)
- Performance Security & Financial Assurance
- Insurance & Indemnity Certificates
- Escalation & Dispute Resolution Matrix
- Change Order & Amendment Process
- Termination & Exit / Demobilization Plan
- Compliance & Permits Confirmation
- Confidentiality & Data Protection Addendum
-
Deployment
Operationalize rollout with readiness checks, enablement, and outcome validation.
-
Pre-Deployment Readiness
Confirm permissions, connection timelines, SCADA access, quality specs, insurance, and contingency plans are in place before work begins.
Readiness Questions
Quick Intro — Who You Are and What’s Pushing This Now
- Please share your role, team, and the company you represent (so we know who’s in the room).
- What product(s) are you focused on for this engagement?
- What is the primary business driver behind exploring storage/transport options today?
- How soon do you need a solution in place?
- What target volumes and duration are you considering (provide typical monthly bbls and expected months)?
If Your Takeaway Bottlenecks Had a Voice, What Would It Complain About?
- When deliveries get constrained, what single consequence hurts you most—lost sales, forced flaring, refinery underfeed, or margin compression?
- How frequently over the past 12 months have you experienced apportionment, tankage shortages, or pipeline constraints that changed your plans?
- Can you describe one recent event where a capacity issue forced a last‑minute operational or commercial decision? What happened and what did it cost (time, $s, relationships)?
- Which of the following outcomes from a storage partner would reduce those pains most for you?
- How does experiencing these constraints make you or your team feel—frustrated, risk-averse, reactive, or something else?
Where Do Your Barrels Actually Live Today? A Map We Can Learn From
- What are the primary origin points (fields, terminals, hubs) and the usual flow paths to your buyers or terminals?
- Which physical storage types are you currently using and in what proportions?
- Tell us about your connectivity needs — which market hubs or downstream interconnects are must-haves for your strategy?
- Do you currently have SCADA/data feeds into your storage or transportation partners? If so, what level of telemetry and latency do you receive?
- How much heel (minimum inventory left in tank/cavern) flexibility do you need to support your operations or trading strategies?
- Are there specific product quality specs or contamination sensitivities we must know up front (API gravity, sulfur, water, additives)? Please list critical thresholds.
When the System Breaks — The Real Failure Modes We Must Plan For
- Think of the worst delivery failure you've experienced—what was the root cause (logistics, quality, communication) and what stopped you from recovering faster?
- Which of these operational failures have you actually seen in the field?
- When a quality or contamination issue arises, who within your organization leads remediation and what steps are expected before accepting product back into the supply chain?
- Have you had to pay demurrage, penalties, or make whole payments because of scheduling or connection failures? Describe the typical triggers and the financial impact range.
- What contingency behaviors have you used historically (e.g., truck out, reroute, soak storage) and how well did they mitigate cost/risk?
What Would ‘Win’ Actually Look Like—Beyond a Low Rate
- If this engagement succeeds, what three measurable outcomes will tell you we achieved the goal (e.g., days of available storage, reduced apportionment, improved cash margin)?
- What are your acceptable delivery windows and tolerance for slippage on nominations (minutes/hours/days)?
- How important is optionality to your strategy—do you need the ability to redirect barrels to different hubs on short notice?
- Which operational KPIs matter most to you for ongoing success monitoring?
- How would a successful short pilot change the way your commercial or trading teams behave—more aggressive swaps, longer commitments, or different hedging?
Deal-Breakers Versus Nice-to-Haves — What We Must Nail Contractually
- Which contractual elements are non‑negotiable for you to sign (pick all that apply)?
- Do you prefer committed firm capacity, interruptible capacity, or a blended approach for this use case?
- What contract length and rate structure aligns with your risk appetite (term, CPI linkage, fixed vs indexed, per-barrel-per-month)?
- What contamination acceptance criteria or testing protocols do you require before product is accepted or paid for?
- What level of insurance coverage and certificates of insurance does your organization require from a storage/transport provider?
Integration & Go‑Live — Are Your Teams Ready to Move Fast?
- Do you have an internal technical owner for SCADA/data integration and what access level can they grant (read-only telemetry, write/controls, API access)?
- What lead time do you realistically need for physical connections, permits, and safety reviews before first movements can begin?
- Who will own day-to-day nomination alignment and who is the escalation contact if nominations are missed?
- Which training or enablement will your operations team need from us before go‑live (SCADA onboarding, nomination procedures, quality sampling, emergency response)?
- What milestones and owners would you expect on a go‑live timeline to feel confident about launch?
Decision Makers, Approvals, and Hidden Hurdles — Who Actually Signs Off?
- Who are the decision makers and approvers for commercial, legal, and operational sign-off (names and roles if possible)?
- What approval criteria will the commercial VP or procurement team use to say yes (rate benchmarks, strategic optionality, collateral requirements)?
- What typical internal review cycles or committees (finance, legal, safety) could delay approval and how long do they usually take?
- Are there budget windows, hedge timelines, or node-specific considerations that constrain when you can commit?
- What single obstacle, if not addressed now, would most likely stop this deal from moving forward?
A Small, Low-Risk First Step — What Would You Try First?
- If we proposed a pilot to prove capability, what minimal scope would convince you to expand (e.g., one terminal, X bbls for Y weeks)?
- What acceptance criteria would you use to judge pilot success (volume handled, nominations filled on-time, zero contamination events)?
- How quickly could you mobilize test volumes if commercial terms and technical access were agreed?
- Who should be on the pilot steering team from your side (roles preferred, not necessarily names)?
- What would make you say ‘this pilot is worth scaling’—and what would make you stop it early?
-
Deployment Enablement
Schedule connection works, SCADA integration, nomination alignment, training, and go‑live sequencing with clear owners and milestones.
-
Validation Checklist
Verify physical connectivity, data feeds, first nominations, product quality acceptance, and operational handover to confirm readiness.
Validation Questions
Start with One Quick Confirmation
- Who is the primary day‑of contact we should reach for connectivity and access issues?
- Please provide that contact's name, role, phone, and email.
- Which channels should we use for urgent operational alerts (pick all that apply)?
- What is your confidence level that the connection window and site access are cleared for the planned handover date?
Are We Truly Physically Connected?
- Tell us about any physical connection gaps you’re holding onto—are we missing flanges, meter runs, valves, or permits that block flow?
- Select the status that best describes each nominated interconnect point today.
- If any connection is partial or pending, which specific sites or tie‑ins need vendor/contractor work and what is the estimated completion date?
- Are any third‑party operators or shippers required to enable physical flow through your network? If so, who and what approvals are outstanding?
- How would you describe the biggest emotional or commercial concern about achieving physical connectivity on day one?
Is the Data Pipeline Honest?
- If your SCADA, EDI, or API feeds were suddenly unavailable for 24 hours, what would that reveal about our readiness?
- Which telemetry and data feeds do you require as minimum for go‑live?
- Have feeds been connected and authenticated to our test environment, and have you reviewed at least 48 hours of historical data?
- When you reviewed historical data, did you see consistent timestamps, matching totals between meter and tank reads, or any obvious gaps?
- Who owns data reconciliation and discrepancy resolution on your side (Ops, Commercial, IT, or third party)? Provide name/role if possible.
Will First Nominations Land Where We Think?
- What single assumption about your nominations process would you be most worried about being wrong on day one?
- Describe the end‑to‑end flow for your first nomination: who prepares it, who approves, who transmits, and which system confirms it?
- Which nomination windows and cadences must we support for the first 30 days?
- Do you expect any priority rules, apportionment risk, or scheduled outage conflicts that could force delivered volumes below your nominations?
- Who on your team will own nomination exceptions and communications during week‑one (name, role, preferred contact)?
Do Product Specs Feel Like a Safe Bet?
- If a load arrives and fails product acceptance, what single outcome would be worst for you (rejection, reblend, additional testing delay, commercial penalty)?
- Are final product specs, contamination limits, and testing methods mutually agreed and documented?
- Do you require onsite sampling and third‑party lab analysis, or will COAs/rapid field tests suffice for initial acceptance?
- If an inbound shipment fails spec, what remediation path and cost allocation do you expect (e.g., reblend, return at shipper cost, keep with discount)?
- How comfortable are you with the current contamination‑control procedures at our facility (sampling frequency, tank cleaning, segregation)?
Who’s Really Taking the Baton?
- If we handed over full operations tomorrow, what single operational responsibility would you still expect our team to perform?
- Who is your named operations lead for custody transfers and first‑line troubleshooting (name, role, 24/7 contact)?
- Which responsibilities should remain shared vs owned by us after formal handover? (choose all that apply)
- What objective acceptance criteria should we hit before declaring final operational handover (examples: X consecutive successful nominations, 0 quality rejections, T+Y reconciliation accuracy)?
- How would you like the first 30–90 day operational governance to be structured (meeting cadence, reporting format, KPIs)?
If the System Trips, Do We Have a Playbook?
- Name the top three failure scenarios you fear most during the first 90 days (e.g., SCADA outage, contamination, pipeline apportionment).
- For each failure above, what immediate mitigation steps do you expect and who is authorized to execute them?
- Do you have alternate offload or storage routes available if primary delivery is blocked?
- What maximum time‑to‑recover (TTR) would trigger commercial remedies or reroute decisions for you?
- Would you like us to run a pre‑go‑live tabletop or live drill to exercise these failure modes, and if so which format?
Confirming Next Steps — Close the Loop
- Looking at all of the above, what single unresolved item would prevent you from signing off on go‑live?
- Which of the following deliverables would make you feel most confident that we're ready to proceed (pick top two)?
- Who needs to sign the final validation checklist on your side (name, role) and what is the internal timeframe to secure that approval?
- Set a proposed date for a joint validation call or site walk — when can your full team be available?
- How would you rate your overall emotional readiness for go‑live on a scale from 1 (apprehensive) to 5 (confident), and what would move you one point higher?
-
-
Success
Review performance against success metrics, capture lessons learned, and maintain a shared backlog for issues and enhancements.
Success Reviews
- Success Metrics Review (Executive)
- Operational Handover & Validation Summary
- Lessons Learned Workshop (Cross-Functional)
- Customer Satisfaction & Commercial Reconciliation
- Backlog Grooming & Roadmap Planning
Issues & Enhancements
- Issue a reconciliation packet with supporting SCADA and nomination records for disputed invoices.
- Introductions & Purpose
- Ensure operational incidents are understood, remediated or scheduled, and documented.
- Confirm data integrity of SCADA and nomination reconciliations for downstream billing and reporting.
- Establish clear owners and criteria for item closure and operational readiness.
- Produce RCA documents for all incidents marked 'in progress' with target close dates.
- Update SOPs and publish changes to shared document repository; notify affected teams.
- Run a scoped SCADA reconciliation between parties and report mismatches within 5 business days.
- Workshop Frame & Rules
- Produce a prioritized backlog of operational, commercial, and technical improvements.
- Agree clear owners, acceptance criteria, and timelines for the top 5 backlog items.
- Document the one-sentence current state and future-state outcome statements for validation and future solution experiences.
- Populate the shared backlog with prioritized tickets and business-impact scoring.
- Assign owners and draft acceptance criteria for each top-priority backlog item.
- Schedule targeted working sessions for high-effort items (engineering, SCADA, contract changes).
- Opening & Scope
- Resolve or establish timelines for all outstanding commercial disputes and claims.
- Agree on SLA credit calculations and settlement approach with evidence trail.
- Capture contract improvement items to reduce recurrence of similar disputes at renewal.
- Welcome & Objectives
- Apply agreed SLA credits or draft credit memos and route for approvals.
- Draft proposed contract amendments addressing identified commercial gaps for legal review.
- Recap Backlog Purpose & Policies
- Produce a prioritized, time-bound roadmap for backlog items with named owners.
- Ensure customer-critical items are scheduled with clear milestones and contingency plans.
- Establish a regular cadence for backlog grooming and progress reporting.
- Create project tickets for roadmap items with milestones and link to customer impact statements.
- Notify stakeholders of planned delivery windows and owners for each roadmap item.
- Schedule the next backlog grooming session and set the reporting cadence (weekly/biweekly/monthly).
- Provide clear visibility to executives on whether success metrics were met and why.
- Agree on executive-level corrective actions or commercial reconciliations for material variances.
- Set timelines and owners for follow-up deep dives and remediation work.
- Deliver a full metric deep-dive pack (per-metric drilldowns, raw data, and trend analysis).
- Issue executive decision memo documenting agreed escalations and approvals.
- Schedule remediation review meeting with assigned owners within 10 business days.
- Review New Items Since Last Grooming
- Incident & Outage Summary
- Recap of Agreed Success Metrics
- One-Sentence Current State
- Invoice & Nomination Reconciliation
- Consequence Mapping
- Dashboard Walkthrough
- Quality & Contamination Events
- Prioritize Top 10 Items
- SLA Credit & Penalty Review
- Consequence & Impact Summary
- Roadmap & Milestone Assignment
- What Worked / What Didn't
- Contamination & Quality Claims
- SCADA/Data Integrity & Nominations
- Commercial Remedies & Contract Lessons
- Top Variances: Root Cause Snapshot
- Operational Process Changes & SOP Updates
- Risk & Contingency Review
- Root Cause Brainstorm & Diagnosis
- Commitments, Reporting Cadence, Close
- Agreement & Sign-Off Plan
- Open Issues and Closure Criteria
- Executive Decisions & Escalations
- Backlog Creation & Prioritization