Supply Chain Execution Software
Platform decisions with deep integration complexity, organizational change, and long-term data stakes.
Inside this journey
-
Pre-Discovery
Align decision makers, success metrics, and pilot constraints before deep evaluation.
-
Stakeholder Alignment
Confirm executive success metrics, decision roles (VP, CIO, CFO), pilot constraints, and timeline for the 60-day sandbox evaluation.
Alignment Questions
Quick Grounding — Where Are We Starting?
- Which distribution center, region, or business unit will run the 60‑day sandbox?
- Who is our primary day‑to‑day contact for the pilot (name, role, preferred contact method)?
- Which executive is sponsoring the evaluation and who will be the VP-level champion driving the decision?
- Roughly how many orders and SKUs does this DC process on a typical day and at peak?
- Do you already have a preferred 60‑day window in mind for the sandbox, or are you open to proposal?
If This Breaks Again, Who Gets the Call?
- When a fulfillment failure occurs today (late shipments, spikes in mispicks, or backorders), who within your org feels the immediate pressure?
- Tell us about a recent breakdown that reached the executive level—what happened, how long did it take to surface, and what was the business impact (revenue, fines, customer churn)?
- How do those incidents translate into measurable costs or penalties for your business?
- Which SLA or customer promise is most fragile right now and would be the first to fail under higher volume?
What Does ‘Success’ Look Like for Each Executive?
- If you had to name the single most important metric that convinces the VP of Distribution this is working, what would it be (and target value)?
- How will the CIO evaluate technical success—what integration depth or data fidelity must be proven in the sandbox?
- For the CFO: what payback timeline and ROI threshold would make this a go‑forward investment (e.g., payback < 12 months, IRR %, or NPV target)?
- Beyond raw numbers, what qualitative signals would convince each executive—e.g., reduced escalations, simpler vendor consolidation, or visible floor‑level adoption?
Where Your ERP Is Really Hitting the Ceiling
- Which ERP/order management system is the source of truth today for orders and inventory?
- Describe one specific operation the ERP performs today that you believe is causing the most friction (wave planning, putaway, labor allocation, cartonization, carrier selection, etc.).
- How real‑time is your order and inventory data—are you operating on near‑real time, hourly batches, or end‑of‑day snapshots?
- What integration touchpoints must we validate in the sandbox to prove feasibility (examples: order ingestion, confirmations, ASN, inventory sync, carrier tender)?
- Are there internal policies or customizations within the ERP that will affect how we map orders and fulfillments in the sandbox?
The 60‑Day Sandbox — Your Non‑Negotiables and Hidden Rules
- If the sandbox could only prove three things to get a pilot extension or purchase, what three proofs would you insist on?
- Which acceptance criteria must be met for the sandbox to be declared successful (pick rate uplift, accuracy delta, labor hours saved, cartonization rate, carrier SLA attainment)?
- What constraints must the sandbox respect (no changes to live WMS, limited access to production data, masked PII, specific audit requirements)?
- Are there any compliance, security, or legal gatekeepers that will need to sign off before we access historical order data for the sandbox?
- What would be a dealbreaker that would end the evaluation prematurely?
Who Holds the Keys — Decision Roles and Influence Maps
- List the individuals or roles that must approve a purchase after the sandbox (name and role if possible).
- Which role will have final sign‑off on commercial terms and who will own the budget for the multi‑year license?
- How does your internal approval process generally work—consensus across stakeholders, single approver, or procurement-driven negotiation?
- Who is likely to be skeptical of replacing ERP-embedded warehouse logic, and what evidence would persuade them?
- Are there external partners (3PLs, carriers, integrators) whose buy‑in will be required during or after the pilot?
What Could Go Wrong — Risks You’re Quietly Worried About
- If the pilot underdelivers on the metrics you care about, what immediate actions will your team take?
- Which operational dependencies outside our control could cause the sandbox to fail (seasonal peaks, headcount shortages, major promotions, ERP upgrade windows)?
- How comfortable is your operations team with running a parallel process where both systems process orders for a period?
- What contingency budget or resources (people/time) have you set aside should integration or data issues require extra effort?
Integration Reality — Mapping the Technical Steps
- Which specific data feeds or APIs do we need to validate during the sandbox (order headers, line items, inventory on hand, inventory reservations, carrier rates)?
- Who will own the integration work on your side and do they have capacity for sprint-based testing during the 60 days?
- Are there any middleware or EDI gateways we must route through, or can we connect directly via APIs or SFTP extracts?
- How will we validate data parity—what sample size or peak-day scenarios should we run to be confident the sandbox reflects real operations?
- What security or compliance checks must we pass before accessing data (SOC2, encryption, IP restrictions, vendor risk assessment)?
People, Process, and the Floor — Adoption Signals to Watch
- How do you currently train floor staff on process changes and how long does the average ramp to competence take?
- What behavioral signals would show us early that operators are adopting the new workflows (reduced manual overrides, fewer supervisor interventions, scan compliance)?
- Are there union, labor rule, or hourly/shift constraints we must respect during the pilot?
- Who will be responsible for day‑to‑day change management during the sandbox (trainer, ops lead, program manager)?
- If adoption is slower than expected, what incentives or governance will encourage faster uptake (bonus, rate card, executive review)?
Commercial & Governance — What Will Seal the Deal?
- What procurement processes or contractual terms are non‑negotiable from your side (payment terms, SLAs, liability caps)?
- What governance cadence do you expect during the 60 days (weekly steering calls, daily war room, milestone demos)?
- Which commercial signals would shorten your decision cycle (pre-approved budget, a smaller pilot fee, reference visits)?
- Who will own the post-pilot business case and what format does the CFO prefer (cost-savings only, full ROI model, TCO uplift analysis)?
- Are there internal procurement or legal milestones we should schedule now to avoid delays after a successful sandbox?
Clear Next Steps — What We Need from You to Start
- What are the top three actions your team can commit to this week to keep the sandbox timeline intact?
- Which person or email should we send the integration checklist and initial data request to?
- Do you want us to prepare a tailored sandbox plan that includes peak‑day scenarios and the exact acceptance criteria for each executive? If so, who will review it?
- How soon can your IT/security team complete a vendor assessment so we can request data access (typical windows: 1–2 weeks, 2–4 weeks, 4+ weeks)?
- Would you like a short executive one‑pager that maps sandbox proofs directly to the VP/CIO/CFO decision criteria for use in your steering meetings?
-
Current State Mapping
Document warehouse failure modes, ERP limitations, throughput and accuracy baselines, and integration touchpoints.
Current State
Walk Me Through a Typical Shift in Your DC
- How many orders does this distribution center process on an average day?
- Which shifts or hours drive the peak load we should model in the sandbox?
- Which systems are actively used on the floor today (select all that apply)?
- Describe your order mix—% of single-line vs multi-line vs parcel vs LTL shipments (brief breakdown).
- How would you summarize the morale or daily friction on the floor when volume is high?
What's Failing When It Matters Most?
- When customers see delivery failures, which single process or system do you instinctively point to as the root cause?
- Which failure modes occur most often? Select all that apply and estimate frequency.
- Give one recent incident where a fulfillment breakdown reached an executive or customer-facing channel—what happened and what was the downstream impact?
- How much additional cost or lost revenue do you estimate these failures create (monthly or per peak period)?
- Who on your team currently owns tracking and reporting of these failure modes?
How Deep Is Your ERP's Blind Spot?
- If your ERP is the 'source of truth', where does it fail to orchestrate physical work in the warehouse?
- Describe the ERP warehouse module’s cadence—does it operate in real time, near real time, or batch? How often are orders pushed/pulled?
- What integration methods does your ERP expose today for order and inventory exchange (pick all that apply)?
- Are there any customizations in your ERP that alter how orders are released, split, or cancelled that we should know about?
- How often do ERP-related delays (e.g., order release lag, missing SKUs) directly cause missed ship windows?
Where Throughput and Accuracy Fall Apart
- When volume spikes, which metric collapses first—throughput (picks/hr), accuracy, or labor utilization—and why do you think that happens?
- What are your current baseline metrics for peak-day performance (picks/hour per operator, order accuracy %, lines per hour)? Please provide numbers if available.
- What are the threshold targets you would consider a successful improvement for the pilot (pick rate, accuracy, labor efficiency)?
- How predictable are your peak events—do they follow known seasonality, promotions, or are they emergent/unexpected?
- Which physical constraints amplify failures (narrow aisles, mixed case complexity, staging areas, packing bottlenecks)?
What Integration Touchpoints Could Break the Pilot?
- Which single integration point worries you most for a 60‑day sandbox: order feed, inventory sync, carrier handoff, or acknowledgement flows?
- List the exact data elements and cadence we must consume or provide for the sandbox (e.g., order header, order lines, ship-to, promised date, inventory by bin).
- Who is the technical owner for each touchpoint (ERP owner, middleware, network ops, 3PL) and who will provide access for the sandbox?
- What middleware or integration layers sit between your ERP and floor systems today (select all that apply)?
- Do you have a sandbox/QA ERP instance we can integrate with, or will we need to operate against production with read-only extracts?
Who Pays Attention When Things Go Wrong?
- If a pilot day shows accuracy slipping by 2–3 percentage points, who gets notified and who makes the call to pause or change scope?
- What governance cadence would you prefer during the sandbox—daily standups, weekly KPI reviews, or event-driven escalation?
- What are the CFO’s minimum acceptance signals for this pilot to be considered in commercial modeling (payback window, labor savings %, error reduction)?
- Who will be the single executive sponsor for the pilot and who will act as the integrator/point person day-to-day?
- How do you prefer success to be reported during the pilot—raw logs and dashboards, executive summary, or both?
If We Could Change One Thing Overnight, What Would It Be?
- Imagine one operational constraint disappears tomorrow—what single change would most improve throughput or accuracy?
- Which outcome would justify a rapid go/no-go decision after the 60‑day sandbox (specific % improvements or $ savings)?
- What sandbox acceptance criteria would make your CIO comfortable advancing integration beyond the pilot?
- If change management fails on day 30, what are the leading causes you’ve seen historically (training, UX, incentive misalignment)?
- What would a low-friction pilot look like to your frontline teams—parallel run with same orders, shadow mode, or phased cutover?
The Risks You Know — And The Ones You Don't
- What single risk would keep you up at night during a 60-day sandbox (data integrity, security, carrier failures, or adoption)?
- Please identify known technical constraints (rate limits, missing data fields, latency SLAs) and how often they surface.
- Which compliance or audit requirements must the sandbox meet (PCI, SOC, customs, retailer SLAs)?
- Which operational risks are most underestimated internally (e.g., temporary labor skill gaps, inaccurate bin locations, seasonal SKU churn)?
- What contingency plans do you already have for integration failures or unexpected data gaps during a pilot?
Let’s Make The Sandbox Real—Who, What, When
- Who will be on the core pilot team from your side (names/roles): integration lead, ops lead, data steward, exec sponsor?
- Which 60 days of order history should we use for the sandbox and are there special dates (promotions/peak events) we must include?
- What minimum dataset can you commit to providing and by what cadence (order history, inventory by bin, carrier manifests, item master)?
- What is your desired go/no-go decision date after the sandbox completes?
- Is there anything else we haven’t asked that would materially affect the sandbox scope or acceptance criteria?
-
-
Outcome Discovery
Define target pick rates, order accuracy, labor productivity improvements, and CFO payback criteria for ROI modeling.
Discovery Questions
Setting the Table: Quick Snapshot
- What's your role and how are you involved with this distribution center or network?
- How many orders does this site typically ship on an average day and on a peak day?
- What ERP/WMS stack is currently running the order orchestration and which parts do you consider underperforming?
- Are you currently planning or committed to a 60‑day sandbox evaluation for a new execution platform?
- Briefly, tell us about the last time a fulfillment failure became visible to your customers—what happened and who raised the alarm?
Are You Settling for 'Good Enough'?
- If these fulfillment breakdowns repeat next peak season, what is the real business cost (dollars, lost customers, executives’ attention)?
- Which failure mode feels most out of control today: late shipments, mispicks, backorders, or throughput collapse under peak load?
- How often are these high‑impact failures happening today?
- When these issues happen, how does it feel internally—embarrassing, urgent, tolerated, or something else?
- Which customer segments or channels suffer most when these breakdowns occur (e.g., e‑commerce, store replenishment, B2B)?
Where the Numbers Actually Hurt
- If you had to name one metric that would determine whether this DC keeps running under the current model, what is it?
- What is your current baseline for picks per hour (average across shifts)?
- What is your current order accuracy percentage (line-level or order-level)?
- How do you currently measure labor productivity (picks/hr, orders/hr, cost per order)? Please share the metric you use and the value.
- What target pick rate and order accuracy would make this pilot a clear operational win for your operations team?
- What CFO payback threshold (months to payback or other financial criteria) would be required for a rollout decision?
Who Holds the Keys (and What's at Risk)?
- If the CFO said 'no' unless you hit a specific payback window, how would that reshape your operational targets or pilot scope?
- Who will make the final decision to purchase and who signs on rollout funding?
- Who will own ERP integration work and data extracts during the sandbox?
- What availability and time commitment can your operational SMEs and IT commit to the 60‑day pilot (hours/week)?
- What are the non‑negotiable risks or constraints (data security, blackout windows, union rules) we must plan around?
If This Worked Perfectly, What's on the Scoreboard?
- Imagine a pressable business outcome after rollout—what single metric would you most want to celebrate publicly?
- What percentage uplift in labor productivity would you consider transformational for this site?
- What absolute order accuracy rate would remove most operational headaches for your customer service and finance teams?
- Besides labor and accuracy, which business outcomes matter most to your leadership?
- How quickly do you expect improvements to translate into financial results (months after go‑live)?
What Must We Prove in the 60‑Day Sandbox?
- If we could only demonstrate three outcomes in the sandbox that would convince your CFO, which three would they be?
- Do you have at least 60 days of historical order and fulfillment data available for sandbox use?
- Which peak-day scenarios must be included in the sandbox (select all that apply)?
- Which modules do you require demonstrated in the sandbox to consider the pilot valid?
- What acceptance thresholds for pick rate, order accuracy, and labor improvement do you want documented before declaring pilot success?
- Do you require that the sandbox run in parallel against live orders (shadow mode) or is a replayed/historical simulation sufficient?
Why Have Past Pilots Stalled?
- What was the single biggest reason a prior pilot or project did not scale at your company?
- Which of these root causes have you experienced before?
- Have you previously run pilots that required ERP integration? What went well and what broke down?
- How would you rate your org’s change readiness for new floor-directed workflows?
- What governance cadence (meetings, KPIs, escalation path) proved effective or missing in past pilots?
- What budget approvals or sign‑off thresholds historically delayed pilot-to-rollout decisions?
Small Bets That Build Confidence
- If we designed one low-risk test in week one that would earn executive trust, what should it prove?
- Which data extracts can your team share within 2 weeks to start the sandbox?
- Who will be our primary day‑to‑day point of contact and who needs executive visibility during the 60 days?
- How soon can you commit to a sandbox kickoff once access is granted?
- Would a joint success plan with weekly KPIs and a CFO-ready ROI dashboard make you more comfortable committing to a pilot?
- Are there any legal, procurement, or commercial guardrails that would block the pilot or constrain its scope?
-
Solution Experience
Use the customer’s historical orders and peak-day scenarios to demonstrate how the platform sustains throughput, accuracy, and labor targets in the sandbox.
Experience Meetings
- Solution Experience Kickoff — Current State & Success Criteria
- Data & Scenario Preparation Workshop
- Sandbox Simulation — Controlled Peak-Day Run (Live Observation)
- Results Analysis & CFO Business Case Review
- Stakeholder Validation & Pilot Acceptance
- Agree on remediation steps or sign-off to progress to pilot planning.
- Produce run artifacts (dashboards, logs, sample pick flows) that demonstrate whether targets are met under peak stress.
- Show direct remediation of key failure modes and quantify time-to-recovery improvements.
- Elicit immediate validation from operations, IT, and finance stakeholders on whether the observed behavior matches needs.
- Identify any data or configuration gaps that require a re-run or adjustment.
- Seller: Export timestamped KPI reports, event logs, and sample pick/ship traces for post-run analysis.
- Customer Ops: Review observed workflows and flag any deviations from expected floor behavior.
- Seller: Document any configuration changes applied during the run and their rationale.
- Customer IT: Confirm whether any integration behaviors observed require changes to ERP order management mapping.
- Executive Summary of Sandbox Results
- Validate whether sandbox results meet acceptance criteria and identify any blockers.
- Deliver a CFO-ready business case with a documented payback period and sensitivity ranges.
- Introductions & Meeting Objectives
- Seller: Produce the final sandbox results report with annotated proof points, root-cause notes, and a CFO-facing ROI deck.
- Customer Finance: Provide any missing cost inputs (labor blended rate, cost-per-error) to finalize payback calculation.
- Seller & Customer Ops: If required, schedule a targeted re-run window with corrected data or configuration.
- Executive Summary & One-sentence Future State
- Obtain executive sign-off to proceed to the 60-day pilot or a narrowly scoped re-run if needed.
- Agree pilot acceptance criteria, owners, and governance cadence for the evaluation.
- Secure CFO concurrence on the business case inputs and payback expectations.
- Seller: Circulate formal sandbox acceptance summary and pilot statement-of-work for signature.
- Customer: Assign pilot sponsor, DC owner, IT integration owner, and training lead and share contact information.
- Seller & Customer: Schedule pilot kickoff and publish parallel-run cutover plan and training dates.
- Produce and agree a single one-sentence current-state summary to anchor the experience.
- Quantify the business consequence of the current failure modes for urgency.
- Define precise future-state KPI targets and acceptance criteria the sandbox must prove.
- Confirm data owners, delivery dates, and the sandbox run timeline.
- Customer: Provide baseline KPIs (current pick rate, order accuracy, throughput profile, labor cost per hour) and a one-paragraph description of failure modes.
- Seller: Draft and circulate the one-sentence current-state statement and proposed acceptance criteria for customer sign-off.
- Customer: Assign data and IT contacts and provide sandbox access credentials by the agreed date.
- Pre-work Review & Data Inventory
- Confirm all required datasets, owners, and delivery dates for sandbox ingestion.
- Agree on precise peak-day and failure-mode scenarios to execute in the sandbox.
- Finalize ETL mapping rules and baseline validation checks to ensure data fidelity.
- Lock sandbox configuration checklist and schedule the run windows.
- Customer: Deliver 60 days of PII-redacted order history, scan logs, labor schedules, DC layout and carrier rules to the ingestion endpoint.
- Seller: Provide ETL mapping document and sample transformed dataset for customer validation.
- Customer IT: Grant sandbox access and verify connectivity to required source systems.
- Seller: Schedule the controlled peak-day run windows and share runbook with attendees.
- Recap One-sentence Problem & Targets
- Run: Baseline Throughput Simulation
- One-sentence Current State
- Field Mapping & Transformation Rules
- Deep-dive: Misses & Root Cause
- KPI vs Acceptance Checklist
- Run: Peak Multiplier Scenario
- CFO Payback Confirmation
- Scenario Definition: Peak-day & Failure Modes
- Consequence & Cost
- Translate Operational Gains into CFO Inputs
- Sensitivity & Risk Assessment
- Define Future State Targets
- Pilot Scope, Responsibilities & Governance
- Run: Failure-mode Injection & Recovery
- Baseline Validation Plan
- Sign-off & Next Administrative Steps
- Sandbox Configuration Checklist & Schedule
- Decision & Next Steps
- Proof-point Walkthroughs
- Acceptable Scope & Success Criteria
-
Solution Scope
Specify modules (WMS, TMS, Yard, Labor), sandbox data requirements, integration points, and measurable acceptance criteria for the pilot.
Scope Configuration
- Deploy Continuous Wave and Slotting Engine
- Enable Dynamic Pick Path Optimization
- Implement Velocity-Driven Slotting
- Implement Directed Putaway Automation
- Activate Multi-Carrier Rate Shopping
- Deploy Native Transportation Planning and Tendering
- Deploy Yard Visibility and Gate Management
- Activate Labor Optimization with Task Interleaving
- Deploy Cartonization and Pack Optimization Engine
- Integrate ERP Order Management via Real-Time API
- Implement Real-Time Order Reprioritization and Rerouting
- Deploy Scan-Based Pick Verification and Error-Proofing
- Activate Returns and Reverse Logistics Execution
Scope Questions
Deploy Continuous Wave and Slotting Engine
- Do you want the Continuous Wave and Slotting Engine included in the pilot scope?
- Which warehouse zones or DC(s) should be included for wave and slotting testing?
- What wave constraints and business rules must be respected (e.g., carrier cutoffs, staging capacity, SKU consolidation)?
- What cadence do you currently use for waves and what cadence would you like the engine to support (e.g., continuous, hourly, shift-level)?
- What baseline metrics will you use to evaluate wave/slotting success (pick rate pph, travel distance, carton fill, order accuracy)? Select all that apply.
- What slotting inputs are available in your data (SKU velocity tiers, cube, weight, replenishment frequency)?
- Who is the business owner and who is the technical owner for wave and slotting decisions?
Enable Dynamic Pick Path Optimization
- Do you want Dynamic Pick Path Optimization included in the pilot?
- What picking methods are used in the test DC(s) (single order, batch, zone/cluster, pick-to-light, voice)?
- Describe current pick device mix and scanning technology (handheld scanners, wearable scanners, tablets, RF guns).
- What are your target improvements from pick path optimization (e.g., % reduction in travel time, increases in pph)?
- Are conveyors, sorters, or putwall systems part of the pick flow that must be considered?
- What data sources are required to compute optimal paths (real-time location, SKU dimensions, bin coordinates)?
- Who will be responsible for validating optimized paths on the floor during the sandbox?
Implement Velocity-Driven Slotting
- Do you want Velocity-Driven Slotting processed during the pilot?
- What historical window should define SKU velocity tiers for slotting (e.g., 30/60/90/365 days)?
- Are there business rules that prevent moving certain SKUs (e.g., hazardous, temperature-controlled, vendor-managed)?
- What physical constraints must the slotting logic respect (e.g., weight limits, shelf heights, pallet positions)?
- How frequently would you accept slotting changes in production (weekly, monthly, quarterly)?
- What acceptance criteria will confirm slotting improvements (reduced travel, higher pick density, improved replenishment efficiency)?
- What data extracts can you provide to support slotting (inventory snapshot, historical picks, replenishment logs)?
Implement Directed Putaway Automation
- Should Directed Putaway Automation be part of the pilot scope?
- Describe your current receiving-to-putaway flow and any manual steps that should be automated.
- What putaway rules should the system enforce (nearest-fit, velocity-based, reserve space, slot-type restrictions)?
- Are there staging or quarantine areas that require special handling in putaway logic?
- What devices and labels are used on receipts (SSCC, carton barcodes, pallet labels)?
- What reduction in putaway cycle time or putaway errors would you expect to consider this successful?
- Who will own configuration and day-to-day validation of putaway rules during the pilot?
Activate Multi-Carrier Rate Shopping
- Do you want Multi-Carrier Rate Shopping enabled in the sandbox?
- Which carriers and shipping modes must be included (parcel carriers, regional couriers, LTL, TL)?
- What are your shopping priorities (lowest cost, fastest transit, SLA commitments, carbon footprint)?
- Do you have access to carrier rate APIs or do you rely on rate tables/EDI?
- What packaging constraints influence rate shopping (dimensional weight, carrier max dims, palletization rules)?
- What success criteria will validate rate shopping (cost savings %, on-time delivery rate, average transit days)?
- Who is the contact for carrier connectivity and rate credentialing?
Deploy Native Transportation Planning and Tendering
- Should Native Transportation Planning and Tendering be part of the pilot?
- What transportation processes should be covered (load building, route optimization, consolidation, tendering)?
- Which carrier communication methods are required (API tender, EDI 204/210, email, portal uploads)?
- Do you require appointment scheduling and dock window enforcement as part of tendering?
- What constraints drive planning (weight limits, trailer types, hazmat, customer delivery windows)?
- What KPIs will determine successful transportation planning in the pilot (load fill %, tender acceptance rate, on-time departure)?
- Who owns carrier contracts and who will approve tendering rules during the pilot?
Deploy Yard Visibility and Gate Management
- Do you want Yard Visibility and Gate Management included in the pilot scope?
- How many gates, dock doors, and typical concurrent trailers does the pilot DC manage?
- What gate workflows are in place today (appointment scheduling, manual check-in, third-party gate system)?
- Do you have yard sensors or RFID/GPS hardware available, or will yard visibility rely on manual input?
- What metrics will demonstrate yard improvement (reduced dwell time, faster gate turnaround, door utilization)?
- Who manages yard operations and will they be available to validate integrations and gate rules during the sandbox?
Activate Labor Optimization with Task Interleaving
- Should Labor Optimization with Task Interleaving be part of the pilot?
- What is your average hourly workforce size in the pilot DC and typical shift patterns?
- What task types should be interleaved (picking, replenishment, packing, putaway, cycle count)?
- Do you have labor standards or time-and-motion baselines to calibrate optimization?
- Are there union or contractual restrictions that affect task assignments or break scheduling?
- What improvement targets justify labor optimization (pph uplift %, reduction in overtime hours)?
- Who will provide workforce schedules and approve optimization rules during the pilot?
Deploy Cartonization and Pack Optimization Engine
- Do you want the Cartonization and Pack Optimization Engine included in the sandbox?
- What packaging types and sizes are in scope (standard cartons, polybags, master cartons, pallets)?
- Do you have dimensional (DIM) data and weights for SKUs available to the sandbox?
- Which packing rules must be enforced (single SKU per carton, prohibited SKU combos, dangerous goods segregation)?
- What success criteria will validate cartonization (reduced cartons per order, cost per shipment, compliance with carrier DIM rules)?
-
Mutual Commit
Agree commercial terms, pilot success metrics, ERP integration responsibilities, and governance for the 60-day evaluation.
Agreement Modules
- Statement of Work (SOW)
- Commercial Proposal / Order Form
- Pilot Success Metrics & Acceptance Criteria
- ERP Integration Responsibility Matrix
- Pilot Governance & Escalation Plan
- Sandbox Access & Environment Agreement
- Data Processing Agreement (DPA)
- Service Level Agreement (Pilot Support)
- Acceptance Test Plan & Validation Checklist
- Integration & Deployment Plan (Appendix)
- Change Order / Scope Amendment
- Payment Schedule & Invoicing Terms
- Intellectual Property & Licensing Terms
- Liability, Indemnity & Insurance Terms
- Termination & Exit Plan
- Renewal & Rollout Commitment
-
Deployment
Operationalize rollout with readiness checks, enablement, and outcome validation.
-
Pre-Deployment Readiness
Validate data access, environment setup, mapping between ERP order management, and assigned owners for integration tasks.
Readiness Questions
Quick Orientation: a single thing to get us moving
- Who is the primary sponsor for the 60-day sandbox pilot on your side?
- Which distribution center will we run the sandbox in, and why was that site chosen?
- When would you ideally like the sandbox to start?
- What single business outcome would make this pilot an unqualified success for your leadership team?
- On average, how many orders does that DC process per day today (ballpark)?
Before We Flip the Switch: the one failure that would break the pilot
- If the pilot failed tomorrow, what is the single most likely cause you would point to?
- How often do peak-day disruptions (late shipments, backorders, mispicks) occur in that DC?
- What are your current baseline metrics at that DC for: typical picks/hour, order accuracy, and average labor utilization? Please provide numbers or ranges.
- Tell us about the last time a fulfillment breakdown reached the executive level—what happened and what was the real business impact?
- Which of these has historically been hardest to sustain during peak: throughput, accuracy, or labor productivity?
Who Owns the Knobs? — responsibility when things go sideways
- Who will be the day-to-day owner we call when an order fails to appear in the sandbox?
- Which teams must approve go/no-go decisions during the pilot? (select all that apply)
- What SLAs do you expect for issue response and remediation when we encounter integration or data problems during the sandbox?
- Who will approve the final pilot acceptance—name, title, and decision criteria owner?
- How often can your cross-functional governance team meet to unblock critical issues during the 60 days?
Where the Data Lives (and Who Can Touch It)
- If we asked for a complete, timestamped order history with line-level details today, can your team produce that within 72 hours?
- How will we get data to the sandbox? (select all methods that apply)
- Which ERP/order-management system(s) are in scope for the pilot?
- Are there PII or regulatory constraints on sharing order or customer data with a vendor sandbox? Please describe.
- Which of these data elements are present and complete in your order feed today? (select all that apply)
The Real Integration Gaps: honest choices, not wishful thinking
- Which single integration touchpoint has caused the most overruns in past projects?
- Do you currently use middleware/iPaaS for integrations, or do you prefer direct connections?
- Are your current integrations batch (hourly/daily) or near real-time? How tolerant is the business of latency?
- Which mapping complexities do we need to plan for (e.g., multi-UOM, multi-sku aliases, kit children)?
- Share one example of a past integration failure—what broke and what was the root cause?
People & The Floor: it’s rarely just technology
- Which is more likely to derail a parallel-run: a technical mapping issue or the warehouse team’s reluctance to follow system-directed workflows?
- How prepared is the DC for device-based scanning and guided workflows today?
- How many floor associates will require formal training for the pilot, and over how many shifts?
- Who will be the onsite change champion(s) responsible for adoption during the 60 days?
- Describe one cultural or operational habit that might slow adoption of system-directed pick/putaway guidance.
Sandbox Success: what would make your CFO stop the spreadsheet scratching
- If pick rate improved X% and accuracy improved Y%, what payback horizon would get the CFO comfortable—would that be enough to commit to rollout?
- What specific ROI inputs does your finance team require from the pilot (labor $/hr, error cost per order, implementation CAPEX, ongoing license)?
- What minimum improvements would you need to see in pick rate, order accuracy, and labor utilization to label the pilot a success?
- Who in finance will validate the business case and what evidence format do they prefer (spreadsheet model, slide deck, raw data exports)?
- How will pilot results be reconciled to production metrics—what dashboards or reports must be produced?
Hidden Escalations & Contingencies — planning for what we don’t want to happen
- If the pilot misses a guaranteed ship window on peak day one, who is the escalation path and expected response time?
- Do you have a rollback plan that can be executed within a shift if the parallel-run jeopardizes customer SLAs?
- What regulatory, customer contract, or carrier constraints should we know that might affect how quickly we can change routing or carriers during the pilot?
- Which stakeholders must be notified immediately when a critical pilot incident occurs? (select all that apply)
- What contingency budget or overtime allowance exists to cover corrective actions during the sandbox?
Mapping the Steps to Deployment: the bare minimum we must finish before parallel run
- From your perspective, what are the non-negotiable integration tasks that must be completed before enabling parallel operations?
- For each of those tasks, who will be the responsible owner (name/title) and what is their availability?
- What is your preferred sprint cadence for integration and validation work?
- Estimate realistic durations for the following activities: feed mapping, middleware configuration, sandbox data load, and floor training (give ranges)
- Are there external vendors (carriers, ERP integrators, WMS consultants) we must coordinate with, and how responsive have they been historically?
Commit to Next Checkpoint: timing, credentials, and the first deliverable
- If we agreed to a kickoff today, how soon could you commit the necessary people and credentials to start extract/load work?
- What are the top three blockers that would slow the start of the sandbox (e.g., security approval, API credentials, resource availability)?
- Which communication channels do you prefer for day-to-day pilot coordination? (select all that apply)
- Who should be invited to the kickoff meeting from your side (name, title, role in pilot)?
- What would you like the first 7-day deliverable from our team to be (e.g., sample data load, mapping checklist, device readiness report)?
-
Deployment Enablement
Schedule parallel-run tasks, training for floor staff, integration sprints, and milestone owners for the distribution center rollout.
-
Validation Checklist
Verify pilot acceptance criteria—pick rate, order accuracy, labor utilization, cartonization, and carrier orchestration—then capture results.
Validation Questions
Opening: Who's in the room and why now?
- Please list the people who will be actively involved in the 60-day sandbox (name and role).
- Which executive(s) created the urgency to evaluate a new execution platform?
- What specific incident or pattern triggered this evaluation right now?
- In one sentence, what is the one business question this sandbox must answer for your leadership?
- Who is expected to sign the pilot acceptance and final purchase approval?
If We Keep Doing What We've Done, What Breaks Next?
- When high volume hits again, where do you expect the operation will fail first?
- Tell me about a recent failure that reached customers—what happened, root causes you observed, and the customer impact.
- Which processes routinely require manual overrides, spreadsheets, or ad-hoc workarounds?
- How often do exceptions escalate to senior ops or the VP level during peak periods?
- Who typically owns resolving those escalations and how long does it take on average?
Where the Numbers Hide the Real Problem
- You may be measuring the wrong thing—which operational metric do you think gives the most false confidence today?
- Which KPIs do you track hourly vs daily vs weekly? (select all that apply)
- Please state your current baseline ranges for normal-day and peak-day: pick rate (PPH), order accuracy (%), and labor utilization (%).
- How confident are you in the integrity of the last 60 days of order and execution data we’ll use in the sandbox?
- How do you currently reconcile ERP-reported performance with floor reality when numbers diverge?
What Would a Non-Negotiable Fix Look Like?
- If you had to name three non-negotiable outcomes the pilot must deliver, what would they be?
- Which capabilities must be present in the sandbox to validate those outcomes?
- What operational constraints must the pilot respect (e.g., no downtime, limited change to floor devices, blackout dates)?
- What CFO payback timeframe would make a rollout decision straightforward?
- Are there any acceptance criteria you would refuse to accept? (e.g., >X% accuracy, Y PPH minimum)
Whose Job Gets Harder When You Change This?
- Which teams and roles will feel the biggest day-to-day impact from switching to a single execution layer?
- How do frontline workers currently receive tasks and priorities (select all that apply)?
- How emotionally and practically ready are floor supervisors to move to system-directed workflows?
- What training hours and resources can you commit during the parallel run phase (estimate per site)?
- Who will be the internal change sponsor responsible for adoption success at the DC?
If This Pilot Succeeds, What Changes for the CFO?
- How will finance quantify success—what explicit line items or savings will they expect to see?
- Estimate your current monthly spend (range) on labor and on pick-related rework/error costs.
- Are there capital or operating budget windows that will limit when a multi-year license can be purchased?
- What CFO-level evidence will shift a 'maybe' to a 'go'—a dollar number, a % improvement, or a risk reduction threshold?
- Any finance constraints (e.g., amortization policy, multi-year commitments) we should build into the business case?
Let’s Stress the Sandbox — What Could Break It?
- Which edge-case scenarios make you doubt a sandbox will reflect real-world performance?
- Which historical peak-day scenarios should we reproduce to validate throughput and accuracy?
- What data artifacts can you provide for the sandbox (select all you can commit to delivering)?
- Are there interfaces or systems we cannot replicate in sandbox (third-party carriers, vendor-managed inventory, proprietary telemetry)?
- What SLA do you require for our sandbox environment performance and data privacy controls?
What Would Success Sound Like on Day 61?
- If you answered the VP’s one question on Day 61 in one sentence, what would you want that sentence to say?
- Which specific reports or dashboards must exist at pilot close for you to sign off?
- Who will own the formal pilot acceptance decision, and who needs to be consulted before signing off?
- How will you validate sandbox results against live parallel-run performance before broader rollout?
- What remaining technical or operational risks must be mitigated before a site-by-site rollout?
Quick Signals — Practical Hand-raises
- If we could complete only three integration tasks this quarter, which would you prioritize?
- Data access readiness: which of the following can you provide within two weeks?
- What sandbox timeline do you prefer to validate the business case?
- Who will be the day-to-day point of contact for integration and testing on your side (name & role)?
- Are there security, SSO, or network constraints our team should plan for immediately?
Commitment and Next Steps — Are We Ready to Move?
- What's the smallest high-confidence commitment you will make this week to prove momentum (e.g., provide data extract, schedule kickoff, assign POC)?
- Which pilot governance cadence will you use?
- Who will own pilot acceptance criteria tracking and reporting on your side?
- List any procurement, legal, or procurement windows and blockers we should be aware of before starting.
- Please provide preferred dates for pilot kickoff and a realistic date for having the required data in sandbox format.
-
-
Success
Confirm outcomes against success signals, finalize the business case for CFO, and maintain a shared channel for issues and enhancements.
Success Reviews
- Executive Success Review
- CFO Business Case Finalization Workshop
- Post-Pilot Technical Validation Walkthrough
- Operational Handoff & Continuous Improvement Planning
- Closure & Go-Live Decision Meeting
Issues & Enhancements
- Establish KPI dashboards and a governance cadence to monitor production performance post-rollout.
- Schedule the formal CFO review meeting and circulate materials 48 hours in advance.
- Sandbox & Data Fidelity Statement (one-sentence)
- Validate that pilot technical artifacts accurately represent production behavior and support the business case.
- Identify and assign remediation for any remaining integration or performance issues.
- Obtain technical acceptance from customer SMEs that results are reproducible and sufficient to proceed.
- Document residual technical issues with severity, owner, and target resolution date.
- Provide reproducible test cases and sandbox replay scripts to the customer's IT team for independent verification.
- Confirm monitoring metrics and alerting to be enabled for the production rollout.
- Shared Channel & Escalation Paths
- Agree on a single shared channel and escalation model for issues and enhancements.
- Prioritize and assign ownership to the top continuous improvement items with clear acceptance criteria.
- Introductions & Objectives
- Create the shared collaboration channel and invite agreed stakeholders with defined roles.
- Load the prioritized backlog into the agreed tool (Jira/Asana) and assign owners and target delivery windows.
- Publish the operational playbook and schedule training refresh sessions for floor supervisors.
- Recap Outcomes vs Success Signals
- Obtain formal go/no-go decision for production rollout and document any conditions.
- Confirm contractual/commercial items required for deployment and obtain signatures or commitments.
- Agree deployment timeline, owners, and immediate tasks to transition from pilot to production.
- If go: execute contract amendment (if any), set go-live date, and notify deployment teams.
- If conditional: document required conditions, owners, and dates for a conditional go-live, and schedule re-check.
- Publish the final deployment RACI, cutover plan, and rollback triggers to all stakeholders.
- Executive alignment on whether pilot outcomes meet the previously agreed success signals.
- Surface and quantify any remaining gaps that would prevent proceeding to finalize the business case.
- Obtain clear executive direction (approve, conditional approve, or require more analysis) and assigned owners for next steps.
- Capture any executive questions/gaps and assign owners to provide follow-up data within 3 business days.
- If approved, task the finance lead to begin formalizing the CFO business case document and schedule the CFO workshop.
- If conditional, document required remediation steps and owners with target completion dates for a re-validation review.
- Baseline & Assumptions Review
- Agree on a finalized ROI model and underlying assumptions that the CFO can review and sign.
- Identify highest-impact risks to payback and commit mitigations or contingencies.
- Define the formal approval path and timeline for CFO sign-off and contracting.
- Produce a one-page executive business case and a detailed financial model (spreadsheet) for CFO review.
- Assign a finance owner to collect any missing cost inputs (e.g., headcount FTE rates, integration vendor estimates).
- Detailed Metric Proofs
- Final Business Case Status
- Operational Playbook Handoff
- Current State (one-sentence)
- ROI Model Walkthrough
- Sensitivity & Risk Scenarios
- Consequence Summary (quantified)
- Deployment Readiness Verification
- Integration Health & Error Rates
- Continuous Improvement Backlog Prioritization
- Open Technical Issues & Remediation Plan
- Pilot Results Snapshot
- Integration & Change Management Costs
- Risk Acceptance & Mitigation
- Monitoring & KPI Cadence
- Final Decision & Immediate Next Steps
- CFO Payback Preview
- Validation Checkpoint
- Agreement & Approval Path
- Governance Rhythm
- Validation & Executive Confirmation
- Decision & Next Steps